Politics | New Zealand scraps meeting with Hong Kong democracy veterans
The long arm of China: Murray McCully, Foreign Minister of New Zealand shakes hands with Wang Yi, Foreign Minister of China ahead of their meeting in Beijing in October 2016. Photo: Reuters/ Kenzaburo Fukuhara
The long arm of China: Murray McCully, Foreign Minister of New Zealand shakes hands with Wang Yi, Foreign Minister of China ahead of their meeting in Beijing in October 2016. Photo: Reuters/ Kenzaburo Fukuhara

New Zealand scraps meeting with Hong Kong democracy veterans

Deputy prime minister warned off 'diplomatically sensitive' get-together due to delicate relationship with China

October 21, 2016 12:42 PM (UTC+8)

New Zealand Deputy Prime Minister Bill English canceled a meeting with two veteran Hong Kong democracy supporters this week on advice from his foreign office, he said on Friday, underscoring a delicate relationship with Communist Party-ruled China.

English said in an emailed statement that he canceled the meeting with former Hong Kong legislator Martin Lee Chu-ming and former colonial chief secretary Anson Chan Fang On-sang on the eve of the appointment after he was advised it was “diplomatically sensitive.”

New Zealand has been more careful recently than neighbor Australia not to offend China as both Pacific countries jostle for export opportunities with the world’s second largest economy.

“This is the first time it’s happened to me like this, a meeting was canceled at the last minute,” Lee said.

The former British colony of Hong Kong returned to Chinese rule in 1997 under a “one country, two systems” formula which guarantees it freedoms not enjoyed on the mainland.

Street protests calling for full democracy for Hong Kong in 2014 presented Beijing with one of its biggest political challenges in decades. Dozens of pro-Beijing lawmakers walked out of the Hong Kong legislature on Wednesday to prevent the swearing-in of two pro-independence activists, setting the scene for a new constitutional crisis.

Martin Lee, the founding chairman of Hong Kong's Democratic Party, waits to testify before the Commons foreign affairs committee on Parliament Hill in Ottawa March 10, 2015. REUTERS/Chris Wattie
Martin Lee Chu-ming, the founding chairman of Hong Kong’s Democratic Party. Photo: Reuters/Chris Wattie

Lee has for decades campaigned for democracy for Hong Kong. Chan has said China should trust Hong Kong people to pick their own leader.

China became New Zealand’s largest trading partner after a free-trade agreement in 2008, making New Zealand the first western country to sign such a deal. Exports to China amounted to NZ$12.1 billion (US$8.7 billion) in the year to June, which equates to 17% of New Zealand’s exports.

English, who advised Lee and Chan of the cancellation by email, said that it was “not uncommon” for the Foreign Affairs Minister to advise on meetings with overseas visitors.

Former top Hong Kong civil servant and pro-democracy politician, Anson Chan, holds a press conference on July 6, 2008 to announce publicly that she will not seek re-election to the Legislative Council in the forthcoming September elections in Hong Kong. Chan said she intends to devote more of her time to guidance and mentoring of future electoral candidates. AFP PHOTO/Andrew ROSS / AFP PHOTO / ANDREW ROSS
Former top Hong Kong civil servant and pro-democracy politician, Anson Chan Fang On-sang. Photo: AFP/Andrew Ross

The Foreign Affairs office did not reply to a request for comment on its advice.

In contrast, Chan and Lee last week met with Australian Foreign Affairs Minister Julie Bishop and testified in front of the Australian parliament’s Foreign Affairs Committee about protecting Hong Kong’s autonomy.

New Zealand’s opposition Labour Party legislator David Shearer, who spoke with Chan and Lee earlier this week, said Chinese officials had approached him expressing “concern” about the meeting.

“It’s not in New Zealand’s interest not to go through with a meeting because of persuasion of pressure from another country,” Shearer said.

There were strains in the two countries’ relationship earlier this month when China rebuked New Zealand’s defense minister at the opening of a high-profile security forum in Beijing, criticizing his stance on tension in the disputed South China Sea.

Comments