Central Asia

North Korean, Russian ties firmly on track
By Sergei Blagov

MOSCOW - Moscow has pledged to restore rail links with North Korea, while looking for economic gains from a project that would connect its Trans-Siberian railroad with South Korea.

On August 20-24, North Korea's Kim Jong-il undertook yet another rail trip to Russia, during which Russian President Vladimir Putin told him about the need for a railroad connecting the two Koreas with Europe via Russia, according to the official RIA news agency.

Until recently, Russian officials have been pessimistic about the revival of rail links with North Korea. Just last March, Russia's railways minister Guennady Fadeyev stated that rebuilding the Trans-Korean Railroad and linking it to the Trans-Siberian posed a "huge political risk" while requiring substantial investment.

However, after Putin made his choice, calling the project "important", the railways ministry had no option but to hail the project to upgrade North Korea's rail system to link the Trans-Siberian with South Korea. Subsequently, Fadeyev called this the most promising project in the region. According to RIA, Fadeyev said that his ministry had already conducted feasibility studies and considered possible routes of the link.

Russian railway officials now argue that the Trans-Siberian has several advantages over the sea route as it would slash transport costs and cut transit times to a couple of weeks compared with more than a month by sea. Officials say that joining the Trans-Siberian with the Trans-Korean would enhance advantages, creating the world's longest railroad of 14,000 kilometers. At present only 5 percent of the shipments between Asia-Pacific and Europe go with the Trans-Siberian. According to the ministry, annual capacity of the extended line could reach 500,000 containers and bring Russia up to US$1 billion in transit fees each year.

The project was initially estimated to cost just $250 million. However, now Russia's railway ministry estimates that it could cost about 103 billion rubles ($3.26 billion), including upgrading the North Korean tracks and computerizing signal systems.

On the other hand, Moscow reportedly offered Seoul to repay its $1.7 billion debt to South Korea by "joint" investments in the ambitious rail project, which would open up the 9,000 kilometer Trans-Siberian railway to South Korean exports. The project would revive the Korean railroad system and end South Korea's current reliance on sea freight. There is no indication of a response to this yet.

However, it remains far from certain whether the new route would be faster: freight would have to be transferred onto different train cars because Russia's tracks are wider than Korea's. Moreover, it's still unclear how the projects would be viewed by freight firms and insurers as South Korea is still technically at war with North Korea.

Nonetheless, within the past two years ties between Russia and North Korea have experienced an obvious revival. Putin visited North Korea in July 2000 to become the first Kremlin leader ever to visit Pyongyang. In August 2001, Kim Jong-il traveled 13,000 kilometers from the North Korean capital to Moscow and back on the Trans-Siberian railroad.

Also in 2000, Moscow and Pyongyang signed a new treaty to replace an outmoded Soviet-era accord of 1961. However, bilateral trade dropped from $600 million in 1992 to $115 million in 2001. In January-April 2002, bilateral trade amounted to $33.6 million, including Russia's exports of $30.2 million, according to Russia's trade ministry.

Moreover, some 90 percent of North Korean exports to Russia consist of cheap labor. North Korean workers are typically engaged in forestry projects. For instance, North Koreans plan to harvest some one million cubic meters of wood a year in Russia's Amur region, according to RIA.

Russia has promised to help in rebuilding North Korean enterprises launched during the Soviet-era, including the power sector, although Moscow's aid is conditional on regular payments on Pyongyang's Soviet-era debt. Pyongyang Soviet-era debt to Moscow is estimated at between $2.9 billion and $4.4 billion - the discrepancy is caused by disagreements over the exchange rates of the Soviet-era currencies.

However, Kim's annual rail trips to Russia in his armored express (Japanese-built according one source, and a gift from Josef Stalin to Kim's father, the late Kim Il-sung, according to another version) leave analysts wondering about his true agenda, notably against a backdrop of sluggish bilateral trade.

On August 21 Kim visited Komsomolsk-on-Amur Aircraft Production Association, or KnAAPO, where Sukhoi jets are built for China. The North Korean leader reportedly signed a guest book, noting his "profound respect" for the traditions of Russian aircraft builders. In August 2001, during his previous trip to Russia, Kim also toured a huge tank-building facility in the Urals. Kim's interest in Russia's military plants could be an indication of Pyongyang's appetite for Russian-made arms.

Nearly all weapons used by the North Korean military are obsolete Soviet-made models. Currently, Russian arms sales to North Korea are estimated at some $10 million a year, a minimum level to supply the North Korean army with only most-needed spare parts. North Korea has reportedly sought some $100 million of Russian arms supplies per annum, yet Moscow has been reluctant to extend new loans to cash-strapped Pyongyang.

Moreover, last March there was talk about an alleged Russian plan to build a nuclear power station in North Korea, although the Russia nuclear energy minister eventually dismissed the reports. Earlier this month, Moscow opted to dismiss these allegations again. On August 15, Russian deputy foreign minister Aleksandr Losyukov told ITAR-Tass that Russia and North Korea were not engaged in any "concrete talks on cooperation in nuclear power".

No big wonder that Kim's trips to Russia were quite secretive. North Korean officials reportedly insisted on allowing Russian journalists only to cover the end of the visit. However, not all Russian media outlets appreciated the favor.

For instance, website polit.ru described the visit as a "mixture of businesslikeliness and pathology" and bluntly called Kim "insane". The website also claimed that the presence of North Korean workers, guarded by armed North Korean security officers, amounted to violation of Russia's sovereignty. The practice looks like slave trade, commented polit.ru, which until recently was a pro-Kremlin online project.

However, Kim Jong-il remained uninformed about polit.ru's comments as he reportedly expressed "One thousand percent" satisfaction with his visit to Russia's Far East. Yet it remains far from certain whether Kim's high level of satisfaction was prompted by the rail link plans, the Kremlin's role on the divided peninsula or hopes of receiving fresh Russian arms supplies.

(©2002 Asia Times Online Co, Ltd. All rights reserved. Please contact content@atimes.com for information on our sales and syndication policies.)

 
Aug 27, 2002



 

Affiliates
Click here to be one)

 

 

 
   
         
No material from Asia Times Online may be republished in any form without written permission.
Copyright Asia Times Online, 6306 The Center, Queen’s Road, Central, Hong Kong.