Wary welcome for China's human-rights plan
By Verna Yu
China issued its first action plan on human rights in mid-April, touting it as
a major step forward in its efforts to safeguard the rights of its people.
While lawyers and rights activists have commended the move, they are also
skeptical it will translate into a genuine improvement in rights for ordinary
The Chinese government said the 2009-2010 plan "signals that the human-rights
cause has become a major theme of China's national ... development" and "will
promote the concept of respecting and safeguarding human rights at various
levels of government ... and the whole of society at large".
The 54-page document promises better protection of economic, social and
cultural as well as civil and political rights. It calls for
an end to the extraction of confessions by torture and illegal detention, the
protection of detainees from abuse, and respect for the right to a fair trial.
It also calls for the protection of ethnic minorities, women, children, elderly
and disabled people.
Nicholas Bequelin, a senior researcher at New York-based Human Rights Watch,
said while the plan is not a panacea for the wide range of human-rights abuses
that frequently occur in China, it is nonetheless a "victory" for the
"In itself, the plan is no remedy for the serious range of human rights
violations that we see in China," he said.
But the move nonetheless endorses human rights - long regarded a bourgeois
concept in communist China - as a legitimate cause, indicating it is no longer
a no-go area, Bequelin said.
"It [shows] the battles of the norms have been won, that human rights are
universal and they are accepted by China as legitimate rights," he said. "It
does not lead to any immediate improvement, but by creating a bit of space for
human rights activists, in the long term it might translate into better
Human-rights lawyers in China, who are often harassed for defending dissidents
and journalists, have also applauded the official rights plan though they are
not hopeful it will lead to immediate change.
These lawyers have said the document only consists of a set of guiding
principles - many of which are already in China's constitution - that do not
mandate concrete measures that will result more freedoms being granted to
"I can't see much of a breakthrough in this. Most of the issues are already
included in the constitution, such as freedom of speech and other rights," said
Teng Biao, a lecturer in law at the University of Political Science and Law in
Beijing and a human-rights campaigner.
"They are a set of principle-based and abstract stipulations and lack specific
workable measures. ... Moreover, little is mentioned about the judiciary or
political system, so it's very difficult to have any real impact."
Rights lawyer Mo Shaoping, who has represented many high-profile political
prisoners, including New York Times researcher Zhao Yan and democratic party
organizer Xu Wenli, said authorities have violated rights such as the freedom
of speech and assembly for years, despite them being guaranteed in the Chinese
While acknowledging the plan is an encouraging move, Mo said he is not
confident that the promises will necessarily be translated into action.
"The protection of human rights, including civil and political rights in China
should not be something that exists only on a piece of paper. I think what is
more important is the question of implementation," he said.
For example, the prohibition of forcing confessions through torture is already
stated in China's Code of Criminal Procedure and mentioned in the documents of
the Supreme Court.
"These are rules that date back many years and yet in reality [the abuses] go
on unabated," Mo said.
Meanwhile, international rights body Amnesty International has also pointed out
that in several areas of civil and political rights, such as the death penalty,
torture and freedom of religion, the new proposals simply repeat existing laws
and policies that have failed to adequately protect human rights.
The action plan fails to address many serious rights violations in China,
including the detention and imprisonment of rights activists, censorship of the
Internet and other media, as well as the continued use of administrative
detention for "re-education through labor", which can be used to detain
individuals for up to four years without trial.
Mo points out there are also other major gaps in the plan.
It should have spelt out when China plans to ratify the International Covenant
on Civil and Political Rights, which it signed in 1998, he said.
The plan also fails to address crucial issues on freedom of speech, such as
defining what actions constitute subversion - a blanket charge that has been
used to send many journalists and cyber-dissidents to jail simply after they
criticized the government or called for democracy and freedoms.
"In criminal law, you have a charge called 'inciting the subversion of state
sovereignty' but yet the constitution grants citizens the freedom of speech,"
Amnesty International also said China should take steps to address specific
civil and political human-rights violations highlighted by United Nations human
rights monitoring mechanisms and treaty bodies.
The UN-affiliated Committee against Torture said last year it remained
concerned about the continued allegations of widespread use of torture and
ill-treatment of suspects in police custody.
Cases that have attracted international concern include the jailing in 2006 of
blind activist Chen Guangcheng, who has campaigned against China's strict
family planning policy, and of HIV/AIDS activist Hu Jia last year for "inciting
the subversion of state power".
"For China's human-rights action plan to have real impact on the ground, the
authorities will have to take concrete steps that will meaningfully improve
life for the people," said Roseann Rife, Amnesty International's Asia-Pacific
deputy director, in a statement.
Critics say the Chinese government could have launched the action plan in part
to deflect Western criticism of its human-rights record in a year full of
sensitive anniversaries such as the 20th anniversary of the Tiananmen bloody
crackdown on June 4 and the 50th anniversary of the Tibetan uprising on March
The plan may also have been prepared to help China defend its rights situation
at the Universal Periodic Review of China at the United Nations Human Rights
Council in February this year, Bequelin said.
Bequelin called on the Chinese authorities to stop suppressing human rights
activists, allow a free press and allow international human rights bodies to be
based in China. "These measures would be enough to tremendously help human
rights in China," he said. "If you hide everything under the carpet, the
problems don't go away, they often get worse."
Verna Yu is a freelance journalist from Hong Kong.