Asia Time Online - Daily News
Asia Times Chinese
AT Chinese

    Greater China
     Aug 17, 2010
Babies with breasts shock China
By Kent Ewing

HONG KONG - Once again, China's most vulnerable citizens - its babies - are the central figures in a food-safety scandal. Two years ago, milk powder tainted with the industrial chemical melamine killed six infants and left 300,000 more suffering from kidney stones. Now, some Chinese babies are growing breasts, and their parents are blaming the Nasdaq-listed company that produces the baby formula they were drinking.

But tests conducted by the besieged Ministry of Health have exonerated Synutra International, based in the northern coastal city of Qingdao. No abnormalities were found in samples of Synutra's milk powder or any other formula that was tested, the ministry announced on Sunday. Laboratory tests of 42 Synutra samples found no trace of added hormones that could have led to


the premature development of four infant girls. But this may in fact increase the parents' anxiety: if this was not caused by tainted milk then by what?

The health ministry launched the probe after local authorities in the central province of Hubei reportedly refused parents' demands for an investigation. Three infant girls in the provincial capital of Wuhan and another in Beijing developed breasts after allegedly drinking the Synutra formula. The girls, aged four to 15 months, were found to have levels of the hormones estradiol and prolactin (which stimulate the production of breast milk) exceeding that of an average adult woman. Last week, Chinese media reported that similar cases were also found in other provinces such as Guangdong, Hunan, Jiangxi, Sichuan, Shanxi and Liaoning.

A panel of nine endocrine, pediatric and food-safety experts were assembled by the ministry at the Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention to study the case. The team gathered samples from the markets in Wuhan and Beijing where the suspect milk powder was purchased and from the homes of the infant girls. Samples of some other brands were also gathered from the markets and tested.

From the beginning, Synutra has stoutly defended the integrity of its products and threatened legal action against the media for false reporting.

"While we offer our sympathy to any families experiencing health challenges, we firmly believe that our products are not involved in the claims recently made," Synutra boss Liang Zhang said. "We firmly believe [the tests] will illustrate our unwavering product quality and commitment to consumer safety."

But then, it was exposed by Chinese media that the company might have misled consumers by claiming the milk for making the baby formula in question was imported from "clean farms in the EU [European Union]". Synutra said the milk supplier for two of its baby formulas was Fonterra in New Zealand and the raw material for its third baby formula was from a domestic supplier in Heilongjiang province.

Fonterra issued a statement saying it was "100% confident" in the quality of its milk supplies. Since New Zealand has strict laws prohibiting the use of "hormonal growth promotants" on milking cows, the company said, there is no way its milk could be responsible for the premature development of infant girls in China.

Disturbing as it was to contemplate breasts on babies, the greater fear sparked by this case, on top of many previous food scares, is that there may be nightmares hidden in China's food chain that no one yet knows about. The 2008 tainted milk powder scandal, in which 22 Chinese dairies were named and shamed, prompted a raft of new promises and regulations on food safety, but the unthinkable continues to happen.

A total of 21 dairy officials were convicted for their roles in that scandal; two of them were put to death last year. Still, melamine-tainted milk continues to flow across the country. In July, for example, authorities in northwestern Gansu province seized 76 tons of milk powder that contained up to 500 times the level of melamine allowed by law. The powder was traced to a dairy factory in Qinghai province, which borders Gansu.

Tainted milk powder was also discovered this year in northeastern Jilin province, while dozens of stores in the southwestern province of Guizhou were found to be selling contaminated milk products.

Melamine is commonly used to make plastics, fertilizers and concrete. When added to milk or animal feed, its high nitrogen content boosts protein readings, masking substandard products and endangering public health. The practice, widespread in China's dairy industry, was supposed to end after the shock of 2008. But dairy farmers keep using melamine for one simple reason: it boosts their profits as well as the perceived protein levels of their milk, and regulation remains spotty.

Indeed, some of the same tainted milk powder that was supposed to be destroyed after the horrific revelations of two years ago was reportedly repackaged and sold again to consumers who had been led to believe that a new and more reliable quality-control regime had kicked in.

Against this dark background, some Chinese babies were now growing breasts and, although their condition had nothing to do with melamine, it seems almost inevitable that traumatized parents would seek to blame the baby formula. Memories of 2008 are still burning hot, fueled by continuing revelations about tainted dairy products and typical stonewalling by provincial bureaucrats whose first instinct is to cover up rather than probe any potential scandal. Also in recent memory, 13 babies died in 2004 after drinking a steady diet of formula that had little nutritional value.

But the four cases of premature puberty had the makings of a false alarm from the start. The cause of premature development is not always clear. The condition has been linked to brain disorders or injuries; diet is considered an unlikely cause.

As it turned out, the health ministry's tests vindicated Synutra, whose shares have fallen 35% since the story broke, and it appears that the parents of the infant girls jumped to a false conclusion rooted in past scandals.

China's food regulators can breathe a sigh of relief, but that hardly puts them in the clear. The parents' fears were real, and they are widespread. Rocked by scandal two years ago and buffeted by additional revelations since then, the country's food-safety chain cannot be trusted. No one knows where the next horror may be lurking - and that's the scariest part for consumers already caught up in a frightening story.

Kent Ewing is a Hong Kong-based teacher and writer. He can be reached at kewing@hkis.edu.hk

(Copyright 2010 Asia Times Online (Holdings) Ltd. All rights reserved. Please contact us about sales, syndication and republishing.)

Unpalatable truths in China's food safety (Jan 13, '09)

Milk scandal sours China's 'soft power'
(Oct 10, '08)

1. Obama's Mona Lisa smile

2. Obama has battles in Asia

3. US dips into Mekong politics

4. Sri Lankan waters run deep with China

5. India, Russia squeeze Google Moon racers

6. An education paradox

7. Eyes on the skies over Iran's reactor

8. A mystical journey with Rumi

9. US spying spawns a dystopian epidemic

10. Greening of China an affair of state

(Aug 13-15, 2010)


All material on this website is copyright and may not be republished in any form without written permission.
© Copyright 1999 - 2010 Asia Times Online (Holdings), Ltd.
Head Office: Unit B, 16/F, Li Dong Building, No. 9 Li Yuen Street East, Central, Hong Kong
Thailand Bureau: 11/13 Petchkasem Road, Hua Hin, Prachuab Kirikhan, Thailand 77110