Asia Time Online - Daily News
Asia Times Chinese
AT Chinese

    Greater China
     Oct 14, 2010

China stares past Gates in the Pacific
By Peter J Brown

United States Secretary of Defense Robert Gates was in Hanoi in early October for the first-ever Association of Southeast Asian Nations Plus 8 (ASEAN-Plus 8) defense ministers' meetings at a time when there was considerable discord in Asia.

At these meetings, the ASEAN nations (Brunei, Cambodia, Indonesia, Laos, Malaysia, Myanmar, the Philippines, Singapore, Thailand and Vietnam) were joined by the "Plus 8" nations - Australia, China, India, Japan, South Korea, New Zealand, Russia and the US.

Gates found himself on a stormy sea in Hanoi. Yes, he accepted an invitation to visit China in 2011, but as the time draws near for


his departure from the Pentagon, the significance of his visit there is likely to diminish greatly.

Before Gates leaves his post - probably next summer - he will face mounting skepticism and criticism both at home and abroad. Gates is now part of a team undergoing a radical change, including the selection of a controversial successor to General James Jones as US President Barack Obama's national security adviser.

In Asia, the US war in Afghanistan is reaching a critical milestone and China is continuing its pursuit of a rapid modernization of its military while testing the borders of its neighbors; this is keeping Gates on his toes.

Gates remains a firm backer of the Japanese in its recent showdown with China over a detained captain of a fishing vessel, and while both Japan and China made an attempt to improve relations in Hanoi, there is no sign of a truly significant thaw.

Chinese Defense Minister Liang Guanglie's decision to lecture Japan's Defense Minister Toshimi Kitazawa about how the incident near the disputed Diaoyu Islands between the Chinese fishing trawler and the Japanese Coast Guard demonstrated that Japan still does a poor job of handling sensitive issues affecting both countries, and is proof of a lasting chill. Liang wanted to remind Japan that Japan needs to resolve these and other matters in a way that ensures that China's approval will be forthcoming. Despite any reports to the contrary, China is obviously still angered by the "illegal detention" by Japan of the Chinese fishing boat captain in September. [1]

This lecture was taking place just as China was issuing a terse announcement about its new maritime enforcement policies. Sun Zhihui, director of the State Oceanic Administration revealed that China intends "to strengthen patrols and supervision in order to protect the country's maritime rights and interests".

At the same time, Chinese Premier Wen Jiabao at a meeting in Brussels informed Japanese Prime Minister Naoto Kan that China had no plans to relinquish its claim to the Diaoyu Islands (called Senkaku by Japan) which the Chinese have always depicted as "an inherent part of the Chinese territory".

"The Diaoyu Islands have been Chinese territory since ancient times," Wen told Kan. [2]

This spat has disturbed Gates for months. So when Gates stepped to the podium at the Vietnam National University in early October, he was mindful that the Chinese military was well-represented at the meeting, and that China was still not ready to set aside its important differences with Japan.

Gates informed his audience, "Asia is home to some of the most dynamic, rapidly evolving democratic nations in the world - especially here in Southeast Asia. Southeast Asian nations sit astride key global trade routes, are home to a diverse ethnic and religious population, are playing a leading role in promoting Asian regional institutions, and, increasingly, are stepping forward as vital security partners on a range of regional and global challenges. This is why President Obama has made engagement with our Southeast Asian partners a priority of our policy in Asia."

Gates identified several "core issues" including trade, natural disasters, territorial disputes, terrorism and anti-piracy that "can best be addressed through strong multilateral cooperation. Strong bilateral relationships - amongst all Pacific nations - are critical and they remain critical on their own. But they also build the mutual trust and familiarity necessary for multilateral institutions and initiatives to work - the two are mutually reinforcing. And, increasingly we find that relying exclusively on bilateral relationships is not enough - we need multilateral institutions in order to confront the most important security challenges in this region."

Gates anticipated that his call for ASEAN to recognize the value and benefits of "multilateral institutions and initiatives" would not be well received by China which has avoided anything that might engender this sort of framework and thus interfere with their preference for more fragmented, bilateral problem-solving.

China had a little surprise for Gates, however, in the form of an expressed willingness to "actively get involved in the building of a relevant security mechanism ... to contribute to regional peace and stability," said China's Defense Minister Liang Guanglie.

"So far there is no settled framework for security cooperation in the region due to the complicated situation here with so many countries and so many interests and concerns," said Ma Zhengang, director of the China Arms Control and Disarmament Association. "But China welcomes a fair security mechanism [that] goes in line with China's demand for a peaceful environment to enable continuous prosperity." [3]

The mechanism that China envisions is very much a work in progress, and may only offer a veneer of civility to disputes down the road.

The first question posed to Gates following his speech was an indicator that ASEAN is concerned about the US too, and not just the Chinese.

Gates was asked, "ASEAN highly [values] cooperation with the United States for security, stability and peace in Southeast Asia. But how can we be sure that the United States won't just walk away when their national interests are served in a certain way?"

The questioner did not specify an assumed US commitment to Vietnam alone, by the way, after Gates had spoken very frankly about the very promising prospects for US-Vietnamese cooperation going forward. Gates immediately attempted to remove doubts about the reliability and dependability of the US.

"We have a presence in Asia. We border the Pacific Ocean. We have long-term interests here and we have friendships that go back many, many decades," Gates replied. "I think all Asia can be confident that the United States intends to remain engaged in Asia as we have been for so many scores of years before and that we intend to be an active participant not only in economic and political matters, but also in defense and security matters." [4]

Gates is accustomed to mounting skepticism, both in Southeast Asia and back in Washington. He has always been confronted by critics as well, including retired US Air Force (USAF) Major General Charles Dunlap who blasted Gates in mid-September for steadily increasing the size of the US Army while damaging the USAF on his watch. Dunlap stated that Gates had greatly contributed to the reduction of the USAF's "size, reputation, and combat power".

Dunlap raised questions about Gates, and his climb all the way to the top of the US Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) prior to taking the helm at the US Defense Department - even retelling an old tale about how Gates was once planted in the USAF by the Central Intelligence Agency. [5]

Some of this was old news. Old or not, Beijing might find the notion that the USAF is a hollow force and a second-rate combat power difficult to accept, as Dunlap and others suggest.

After all, the Chinese have watched closely as the USAF conducted and sustained extensive air operations including countless long-range bombing missions over Iraq and Afghanistan simultaneously. The USAF's rapidly growing fleet of unmanned aircraft - thousands are in service - and its determination to extend its reach aggressively into space with all sorts of platforms such as the X-37B are compelling Beijing to rethink its use and positioning of airpower. The impression left by USAF F-22's flying along China's red line in the Yellow Sea and East China Sea during recent exercises in the area cannot be overlooked here either.

The Chinese are certainly well aware that certain USAF officers remain unhappy with Gates following a speech that he gave in April 2008 at Maxwell-Gunter Air Force Base in Alabama.

"This new set of realities and requirements have meant a wrenching set of changes for our military establishment that until recently was almost completely oriented toward winning the big battles and the big wars. Based on my experience at the CIA, at Texas A&M [university] and now the Department of Defense, it is clear to me that the culture of any large organization takes a long time to change, and the really tough part is preserving those elements of the culture that strengthen the institution and motivate the people in it, while shedding those elements of the culture that are barriers to progress and achieving the mission," said Gates. "My concern is that our services are still not moving aggressively in wartime to provide resources needed now on the battlefield." [6]
His speech in Alabama combined with his attempt to shift his cost-cutting campaign into high gear - or at least a higher gear - his call for reducing the number of generals and other senior officers in the Pentagon. This and his capping of the number of advanced US F-22 fighter aircraft built by the US have kept Gates in the hot seat for a very long time.

China may be perplexed not just by USAF officers who criticize Gates, but also by the downgrading of the USAF by the US media as it covered the US military's actions in East Asia in recent months. When the US annoyed China by planning to deploy an aircraft carrier in the Yellow Sea, or moved key US Navy ships during recent North Korean missile tests, for example, these events ensured that the media coverage was overwhelmingly US Navy-centric. The USAF was rarely covered or mentioned.

China cannot rule out the possibility that this is a deliberate ploy on the part of Gates and his team in the Pentagon at this time because the US has worked so hard lately to coordinate air and naval components as part of its emerging "AirSea Battle" master plan.

Regardless, China has an easy task when it comes to detecting that Gates is feeling even more heat at home as the result of his supposed comments about Obama's new National Security Adviser, Tom Donilon, who replaced Jones just a few days before Gates departed for Hanoi.

Gates, according to Washington Post super-reporter Bob Woodward, is quite critical of Donilon, who is described as a longtime Washington insider and one of Obama's closest advisers. In fact, according to Woodward's new book Obama's Wars, not only does Gates doubt Donilon's level of understanding of the US military, but Gates told Jones that Donilon would be a "disaster" as Obama's national security adviser. [7]

Gates finds himself in full damage control mode as a result and has repeatedly gone out of his way to paint a very different picture of his relationship with, and opinion of, Donilon. Gates said that he welcomed Obama's decision to appoint Donilon as the next national security adviser.

"Tom brings a wealth of experience and seasoning into this critical position, particularly from his current tenure as deputy national security advisor. As I can attest from firsthand experience, Tom has been in one of the toughest jobs in Washington and done it well," said Gates in his official comments on Donilon's appointment. "I value the good working relationship I have with Tom and the rest of the Obama national security team and look forward to continuing our collaboration in tackling the many pressing security challenges facing our nation."

China has watched others in the top post in the Pentagon who have encountered vocal and open opposition and then fallen quickly from favor. Some have fallen faster than others. China has also observed the inter-service rivalry which continuously surfaces in the US military.

China recognized months ago that the most powerful US military officer charged with keeping a constant eye on China is not Gates, but US Navy Admiral Robert Willard in Hawaii, who serves as head of the US Pacific Command.

All the ASEAN defense ministers who gathered in Hanoi are well aware of him, so what Willard said recently about the US Navy's size mattered. Willard said that if the number of US Navy combatants fell sharply below the 280 now in service, it would cause him to become seriously concerned.

Gates made no mention of Willard or the US Navy's ship count when he answered the critical question which was posed to him a few days later about the dependability of the US over time.

Adequate number of ships or not, Willard will go on forging a partnership between the US and China - not having China as an enemy is Willard's stated goal. China has been making that objective very difficult to achieve lately.

"We've not been particularly encouraged by the character of what's developed," said Willard. [8]

When Gates walks out of his office for the last time, feeling the heat or not, it will be up to Willard to sort it all out so the US can respond quickly. Willard has his hands full for sure.

1. Chinese defense chief urges Japan to properly handle sensitive issues.
2. Premier Wen reiterates Diaoyu Islands Chinese territory.
3. Beijing backs initiative for Asia security.
4. Remarks by Secretary Gates at Vietnam National University.
5. General: Hey, Newsweek, Gates sure looked different to us in the Air Force.
6. Secretary Gates Remarks at Maxwell-Gunter Air Force Base, Montgomery Alabama.
7. Does the Pentagon trust Tom Donilon, new national security adviser?.
8. Why world's most powerful military man matters to you.

Peter J Brown is a freelance writer from Maine USA.

(Copyright 2010 Asia Times Online (Holdings) Ltd. All rights reserved. Please contact us about sales, syndication and republishing.)

Gates open on departure
(Jun 30, '10)

1. Ahmadinejad steps into a cauldron

2. What really bugs Iran

3. Pakistan stands up for its sovereignty

4. Nobel Committee faces down the dragon

5. The great relocation that failed

6. Bernanke sets the world on fire

7. US cartoons 'made in North Korea' 

8. Tax China and rebuild

9. Lost Asian satellites send powerful signals

10. Al-Qaeda takes a big hit

(24 hours to 11:59pm ET, Oct 12, 2010)


All material on this website is copyright and may not be republished in any form without written permission.
© Copyright 1999 - 2010 Asia Times Online (Holdings), Ltd.
Head Office: Unit B, 16/F, Li Dong Building, No. 9 Li Yuen Street East, Central, Hong Kong
Thailand Bureau: 11/13 Petchkasem Road, Hua Hin, Prachuab Kirikhan, Thailand 77110