Asia Time Online - Daily News
Asia Times Chinese
AT Chinese

    China Business
     May 14, 2009
China syndrome
Max Fraad Wolff

Over the last three- and six-month periods, Chinese stock indexes have led a global rally. China has outdone emerging markets broadly and left US indexes well behind. The iShares FTSE/Xinhua China 25 Index has outperformed the iShares MSCI Emerging Markets Index and the S&P 500. This does not fit standard macroeconomic patterns, theory or intuition.

Leveraged industrial exporters and credit providers do not walk through the blazing destructive fires of the present global economy without getting burned. For 20 years, China has accelerated into the most rapid and sweeping large-country industrial revolution we have ever seen. The changes are real. We are seeing a transfer of industrial production from many locations. Transnational firms from the US, the euro zone and Asia have


come for the infrastructure, wage rates, environmental policy, workers and market. They have also come for the bubble.

It is very difficult to separate the bubble from the real economic revolution. Both are clearly present. For the last four months it has been the bubble that has been the dominant element in China perception and investment. The China-centric emerging market bubble has led us up since February 2009.

For many years the US and China have shared a transnational economy. Chinese lending and export are inextricably interwoven with US import and borrowing. China is now the world's second-largest exporter and is responsible for 9% of world trade. China is the largest source of manufactured imports for the US and the European Union. The World Bank Global Economic Prospects 2009 joins the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development and other global institutions in forecasting a 6% decline in world trade with particularly sharp declines in the US, EU and manufactured goods trades.

China will be seriously and structurally influenced alongside her major trading partners. China's growth rate fell to a reported 6.1% in 1Q 2009, its slowest growth rate in 20 years. China's imports, exports and GDP growth have been falling for six months. April and March 2009 exports were down double digits. A 22.6% decline in April marks a larger fall than the March 17% decline. Chinese firms are growth plays with thin profit margins and huge export markets. These markets require huge import growth and intense free trade policy from importers. Export-driven Chinese growth and lending were part of the same debt consumption system that has been imploding since spring 2007. This is not discussed - it never is in bubbles. It is demonstrably true.

The International Monetary Fund April 2009 Global Financial Stability Report details China as the world's largest exporter of capital in 2008 with 24.2%. The same report details the US as the world's largest importer of capital, at 43.0%. According to US Census Bureau Foreign Trade Statistics for January and February of 2009, the US ran a cumulative trade deficit of approximately $35 billion with China - the US's largest deficit trading partner. In January and February of 2008, the US ran a cumulative trade deficit of $39 billion with China, also our largest deficit trading partner across the first two months of last year. In 2008-2009, our trade deficit with China declined by 10% for January and February. In March 2009, US imports from China declined by $1.4 billion from March 2008.

China's Ministry of Commerce reports the US as the largest trade surplus partner for all months with reported data for 2008. US exports to China were $71.5 billion in 2008 and US imports were $338 billion. This produced a deficit of $266 billion. We are on pace for a China trade deficit tens of billions less this year, on the order of $205 billion to $225 billion.

Markets are now betting that we will import much less and China will lead us back to growth through government stimulus, increased domestic consumer spending and lending.

If any nation could pull of a deft transition from export industrialization to domestic consumption, it would be China. Success will require years, good luck, lower profits and lower growth. To move from global production with transnational partners to domestic production is a sea change in an economy. This means changing what, where, how and at what wages you produce.

For China such a radical transition means much higher wages, different products, marketing and sales. The Chinese economy produces world and export commodities with imported basic commodities and compulsively invests to grow capacity. This will not return revenue growth for the next few years. Recent growth is dependent on huge trade surpluses and lending vast sums to sustain unsustainable, imbalanced exports. This will be increasingly difficult as political pressures mount in China and her export markets. Selling at home means different production methods, wage structures and lower profits. Even if this works, the equity bounce in China has come several years too early.

China's economic relations with the EU, its largest trading partner last year, are similar to those with the US. In 2008, the EU exported approximately $104 billion in goods to China and imported $330 billion in goods from China. There is massive and rising concern in the euro-zone about the size of the deficit and market access for European firms. The euro area is deep into a serious recession. Likewise, South Korea, Japan, Russia - all of which are China's major trade partners - are all in deep structural recession.

Approximately 45% of China's exports go to the US and EU. Exports to the US and EU comprise over 15% of Chinese 2008 gross domestic product at official GDP and exchange rate. A third of Chinese GDP is derived from exports. All major trading partners are presently contracting. That is why we hear so much about their stimulus plan and domestic demand.

We are expecting to see a 20-year growth bonanza based on one economic model seamlessly transition to a different national economic model in six months, with no business cycle point below 6% annual growth. Like American home prices, Chinese growth is always positive.

None of this is to doubt the power and transformation of China. It has arrived as a global power and will continue to do so over decades to come. China has not triumphed over the business cycle. No one ever has and no one ever will. As her imports fall, her energy consumption and generation declines and her shipping tonnage falls - China is struggling.

Middle Kingdom investments are a growth play in a global economy without growth. China has arrived and will suffer as the rest of the global economy suffers. Ironically, it is the weakness that shows that China has arrived. The recent meteoric rise of her shares and indexes is simply the latest in a long string of bubbles. As emerging markets and China have led up lately, it seems increasingly likely they will lead the way down.

Max Fraad Wolff is a doctoral candidate in economics at the University of Massachusetts, Amherst, and editor of the website GlobalMacroScope.

(Copyright 2009 Max Fraad Wolff.)

The world melts, China grows
(May 6,'09)

China's banks in loans dilemma
(May 2,'09)

Truth is too hard to handle

2. Heading over the moon

3. A new fight over the Iran 'threat'

4. Afghanistan defies the US battle plan

5. Taliban on the run in Swat

6. Credulity caught in stress test

7. Which green shoots will wilt first?

8. The czar and the pirates

9. Inflationary musketeers

10. Surviving North Korea's house of the dead

(24 hours to 11:59pm ET, May 12, 2009)


All material on this website is copyright and may not be republished in any form without written permission.
© Copyright 1999 - 2009 Asia Times Online (Holdings), Ltd.
Head Office: Unit B, 16/F, Li Dong Building, No. 9 Li Yuen Street East, Central, Hong Kong
Thailand Bureau: 11/13 Petchkasem Road, Hua Hin, Prachuab Kirikhan, Thailand 77110