Mongolia keeps rail link short
By Munkh-Ochir Dorjjugder
On November 2, the Mongolian newspaper MN-Onoodor reported that the Mongolian
cabinet had adopted a plan to extend the country's railway infrastructure. The
plan envisages the construction of a 1,100 kilometer-long internal railroad to
begin later this year.
The proposed railroad would connect Dalanzadgad, the capital of the
southernmost Omnogovi province to Choibalsan, Dornod province in northeastern
Mongolia. The project will connect what would become the burgeoning industrial
centers of an emerging resource-driven economy.
Southern Mongolia is home to massive deposits of copper, gold and coking coal,
conveniently located only 80 kilometers from its border with China, which is
the largest consumer of these
commodities. Northeastern Mongolia possesses large reserves of uranium and oil,
which are still being estimated, but are strategically located close to both
China and Russia.
This represents a mixed blessing for the contemporary geo-economics of
Mongolia. But this project also is an entirely mixed political puzzle. At first
glance, constructing a railroad directly to China makes much more sense - it is
economically feasible, cost-and time-effective in terms of transportation
expenditure and immediate revenue. After all, as observed by Joshua Kucera in
The Diplomat on March 19, this was the advice of mainstream international
experts and financial institutions, the World Bank and the Asia Development
Bank included.
However, Mongolia leaves this option for the future and meanwhile it will
concentrate on expanding its domestic railroad infrastructure and connecting it
to the Russian system. This decision seems to reflect a cohort of
other-than-economic considerations - geopolitical calculations, aspirations for
sustainable industrialization, and finally public opinion, which matters as the
new electoral cycle unfolds.
Moscow's influence and leverage in Mongolia's railroad industry cannot be
underestimated. Russia controls 50% of the state-owned Ulaanbaatar Tomor Zam
company and uses it to practically block the unrelated project to renovate the
existing Trans-Mongolia railroad using the large portion of a $285 million
grant provided by the Millennium Challenge Account signed with the US.
This fact alone shows that the railroad remains a Russian strategic asset in
Mongolia and a source of potential leverage. Yet, this alone cannot be used as
a single interpretation of the Mongolian overture. It is a strategic ambiguity
that along with its existing dependence on Chinese imports, and even greater
dependence upon the export market for its mineral resources Mongolia may be
more vulnerable politically in making concessions to Moscow.
Accepting Russia as the dominant partner in its infrastructure sector is
rationalized by the need for geo-economic balance, which in the absence of a
direct land route to other major economies Mongolia should seek an equal
distribution of commodity export and transit.
This is partly based on the temporary closure of the border post in Zamyn-Uud
(Mongolia) - Erlian (China) in 2002, ostensibly for "technical reasons" that
also "coincidentally" occurred during the visit of the Dalai Lama to Mongolia.
Moreover, Beijing's recent decision to halt the export of rare earth elements
to Japan prompted the latter to seek suppliers elsewhere; and Mongolia, as
Asahi Shimbun reported on October 4, "has agreed to work with Japan to loosen
China's stranglehold on vital rare earth elements".
Even if Mongolia were to foster such cooperation, it would have to recognize
that its hypothetical exports of rare earth elements could be similarly
blockaded and that this may not result from any mistake by Ulan Bator. Putting
skeptical scenarios aside, there is also willingness to develop long-term,
sustainable industrial growth in order to avoid becoming an economy based on
mineral extraction. En route from Dalanzadgad to Choibalsan is the town of
Sainshand, where the Mongolian authorities plan to build a processing plant for
coal and other minerals in anticipation that it could bring value added
production into the nation's export basket.
The ideal destination for these finished commodities would be the Asia Pacific
markets of Japan and South Korea. Russia has, according to Amarjargal Gansukh,
Mongolia's Deputy Minister for Roads, Transportation and Urban Development in
an interview with the Mongolian new agency in early November, offered three of
its seaports provided that Mongolia connects its railroad to their system. By
adding uranium and rare earth elements to copper and gold to its exports,
Mongolia will secure what it has always sought: stable export markets that
complement the domestic industrial output and job creation.
Finally, few in Mongolia underestimate the importance of public opinion: the
country remains, after all, a participatory democracy and the major parties now
unwillingly look forward to the 2012 elections. Mongolian society has a sense
of cultural alienation from China and fears that growing economic dependence on
its powerful neighbor might evolve into political subservience; the Mongolian
electorate is not sympathetic to any political force even vaguely perceived as
"promoting a Chinese agenda".
This outweighs all rational calculations of the immediate economic benefit and
dwarfs any advice or opinion of Western experts otherwise welcomed and
respected in that society. In other words for Mongolia, Russia remains what it
has always been - an unavoidable partner crucial in balancing China. This has
been true since Tsarist times, the same was true, albeit at a high cost, with
the Soviets, and this also seems to continue with contemporary Russia.
Head
Office: Unit B, 16/F, Li Dong Building, No. 9 Li Yuen Street East,
Central, Hong Kong Thailand Bureau:
11/13 Petchkasem Road, Hua Hin, Prachuab Kirikhan, Thailand 77110
