Korea

The Pyongyang puzzle: By whim or design?
By Francesco Sisci

BEIJING - The political zig-zags taken by the North Korean government are signs of weakness, but it remains unclear whether this weakness is the result of a domestic power struggle or simple miscalculations by Pyongyang's Dear Leader, Kim Jong-il. Even by the standards of North Korea, with its illustrious record of weird behavior, Pyongyang has been acting very strangely ever since October, when it stunned its American guests by admitting that it had a nuclear-weapons program.

In the past couple of weeks North Korea has sent many contradictory signals to the outside world. It kicked the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) inspectors out of the country on New Year's Eve but opened up to dialogue with the United States on January 3 at a news conference in Beijing without raising any preconditions. The day after, however, North Korea added a demand to its offer of direct talks - now it wanted a non-aggression pact to defuse the crisis. Washington rejected the idea, saying it would not reward bad behavior. In the meantime diplomats were fretting around and the South Koreans tried to broker a deal whereby Pyongyang would honor its nuclear commitments in exchange for the United States' resumption of oil deliveries. So on Thursday this week Pyongyang ate its demands about direct talks with the US and informed the South it was ready to reopen a cabinet-level dialogue with Seoul and would send a delegation on January 21.

The talks with South Korea could mark a substantial U-turn away from nuclear saber-rattling and allow us to say happily that we are back to Square 1, where we were before all this started in October: North Korea is once more begging the outside world for help. During this time, however, Pyongyang has proved once more that it is unpredictable and thus difficult to deal with, and even fewer people are willing to talk to it - a net loss for Pyongyang. There is nothing new under the sun, but the question is, Who designed this strategy? Was it the reclusive, shady Kim Jong-il, or have all the sudden turns been responses to an internal power struggle among different factions in Pyongyang?

Anyway, North Korea is back on track and one thing has been made clear by all these U turns. Pyongyang wants to count more in the world scene, but there are no atomic short-cuts to achieve that - economics are what provide real leverage in today's world. However, North Korea's economy is doing badly and even if reforms were enacted more thoroughly than at present, they would still take years to give Pyongyang the economic muscle it dreams of. There is still the possibility of the leverage provided by a road and railway through North Korea linking South Korea and Japan with the Chinese Northeast. If Pyongyang were to have such transportation links, it would have a major bargaining chip for talking with its neighbors, and could gain substantial revenue out of it. A decision concerning a transportation corridor could be a major breakthrough in the coming talks in Seoul. But as Pyongyang has proved so volatile in the past few days, its neighbors could be forgiven for being concerned about giving this token of trust to North Korea. How would Kim play with the transportation corridor? Would he close it every other day to extort some new concessions? Yet China and South Korea, North Korea's closest neighbors, seem to believe that it is important to pave this road.

Still, the current nuclear mess might merely be due to the extreme isolation of Pyongyang and its leaders, who perhaps think along lines much simpler than we might believe. As people in Beijing and Seoul tend to believe that Kim is an absolute monarch, the recent zig-zags may be due to his personal whims.

A couple of years ago Western intelligence discovered in Rome that North Korean intelligence agents were busily buying kitchen utensils and microwave ovens. The Western agents became suspicious and investigated the matter. They found out that some parts of microwaves oven could be used to build triggers for atomic bombs. They thus thought that the North Koreans were about to build an atomic bomb and were purchasing the components of its trigger in the form of innocuous kitchenware. They were about to act and stop the traffic, when they came across another piece of information: The utensils were connected with some Italian chefs hired to go and cook for a period of time in Pyongyang at Kim Jong-il's court. So the Western agents dropped the matter - apparently Kim was simply fond of Italian food. Perhaps he is fonder of pizza than of atomic bombs.

(©2003 Asia Times Online Co, Ltd. All rights reserved. Please contact content@atimes.com for information on our sales and syndication policies.)
 
Jan 11, 2003


Kim Jong-il out-Saddams Saddam
(Jan 7, '03)

Pyongyang: A blot on the map
(Dec 20, '02)

Pyongyang Watch: Guns or butter?
(Nov 5, '02)

Pyongyang Watch: North Korea's bomb: Catch-22?
(Oct 30, '02)

Pyongyang Watch: One weekend's news
(Oct 15, '02)

I made pizza for Kim Jong-il
(Aug, '01)

 

Affiliates
Click here to be one)

 

 
   
         
No material from Asia Times Online may be republished in any form without written permission.
Copyright Asia Times Online, 6306 The Center, Queen’s Road, Central, Hong Kong.