Search Asia Times

Advanced Search

 
Middle East

Words of advice from peace laureate
By Ramin Mostaghim

TEHRAN - Nobel Peace laureate Shirin Ebadi says that Iranian President Mohammad Khatami has "missed opportunities" during his tenure. Speaking to Inter Press Service, the 56-year-old Iranian human rights activist and lawyer indicated her disappointment with his presidency, even as her supporters ride the jubilation that greeted her award.

Ebadi, who on October 10 was announced as the recipient of the 2003 Nobel Peace Prize, said, "President Khatami has done well within the framework of the constitution, but I think the authority of president in the constitution is not strong enough."

The outspoken lawyer explained, "I think President Khatami should have submitted the empowerment bill [to increase the power of the president] and modification of election laws at the beginning of his tenure almost six years ago. Those are the missed opportunities."

Despite her sharp comment about him, Ebadi said. "I respect President Khatami's views concerning the Nobel Peace prize." Khatami, besieged by the press for his reaction to the award as he exited parliament, had called the prize "politically motivated" and "not as important as scientific and cultural awards". She did however add, "I never want to be in power and be a politician. I always want to be with the people and campaign for human rights."

Certainly, in the Yousefabad neighborhood, a middle-class locality in Tehran in which Ebadi lives, the people are convinced that their now-world famous neighbor is firmly with them. An elderly woman, whose son was among the 3,750 political prisoners executed in summer of 1989, a few months before the end of the Iran-Iraq war, spoke to IPS.

She preferred not to be named, but expressed the hope that the Nobel Peace Prize would have an impact on freedom of speech in Iran. She also said she was among those who welcomed Shirin Ebadi home and had taken with her a wreath of flowers, on behalf of all those families whose loved ones were among the executed that bloody summer.

For the present the reaction to the official treatment of Ebadi on her return is still a slow bitterness. "The Iranian middle class have showed restraint and patience even as they shuttled from terminal to terminal at [Tehran's] Mehrabad airport, since the security police intentionally confused people [about where Ebadi would arrive]," fumed Monir Hasanpour, a member of the Iranian Bar Association.

In Iran, news of the award seems to have taken conservative forces in the government as much by surprise as it did Ebadi herself. State-run radio stations controlled by the conservatives waited hours to announce the prize, before finally according it the briefest of mentions at the end of an afternoon news bulletin.

This was in stark contrast to the welcome placards hastily scribbled, but lustily waved, in honor of Ebadi, which read, "Women's rights are human rights," "Our beloved Ebadi, you are the symbol of Iran" and "Political prisoners should be released".

Yet the contrast also highlights the fact that an increasing number of Iranians no longer seem to follow either the conservative or the reformist point of view. Critics among the populace, and there are many, see both as by-products of a moribund system, with the most glaring lack being democracy.

Unhappiness with the government is endemic, and yet there are few mechanisms for public displeasure - especially for the youth and the middle class - to emerge through an effective political outlet. Political and social observers point out that it is likely that Iran will continue to see a struggle between reformists and conservatives, the spread of discontent, and economic change whose pace is far slower than the populace would like.

This is the background for the intensity of the welcome for Ebadi. "Thousands of people came on their own to welcome an Iranian lady, and to shout, 'Shame on you, Khatami'," said Roghiyeh Rahmati, who is 75 and manages to walk with the help of her grand-daughter.

"Iranian hardline newspapers and specially state-run television and radio stations tried to make sure that the least number of people would go to meet the Nobel prize winner," continued Ziba Maleki, the 20-year-old who assists her grandmother.

The fallout of the Ebadi effect will certainly have an impact on the next parliamentary elections in Iran, scheduled for the middle of February 2004. The mood for now is grim. "The next election will be a litmus test for the regime, and people should signal a loud 'no' by not going to the ballot boxes," said Pejman Hajilou, a builder.

Davoud Torbatiyan, an employee with a public sector organization, sees the option as being between "evil and less evil". If the election turnout is low, he believes, "then the hardliners will occupy the seats and the political situation will be worse, so I think I will vote for any reformists who are a bit different".

Ebadi herself epitomizes the differences that exist. Along with other women, in 1994 she founded the Society for Protecting the Rights of the Child, which lobbied the Iranian parliament for introducing legal reforms in line with the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child.

The Nobel laureate has also defended a number of victims of human rights violations. Her outspoken defense of human rights has antagonized the Iranian judiciary, and hardline jurists ordered her arrested in June 2000.

Now she said she is considering "all aspects" about legally representing the son of Zahra Kazemi, the Canadian photojournalist who was beaten to death after the authorities detained her on June 23. "It is too early," Ebadi told IPS. "But I do hope her blood will be fruitful for freedom of speech and expression for all journalists all over the world."

(Inter Press Service)
 
Nov 1, 2003



Ayatollahs grin and bear Peace award
(Oct 15, '03)

Muslim Nobel Prize sends a powerful message
(Oct 14, '03)

 

 
   
         
No material from Asia Times Online may be republished in any form without written permission.
Copyright 2003, Asia Times Online, 4305 Far East Finance Centre, 16 Harcourt Rd, Central, Hong Kong