Asia Time Online - Daily News
Asia Times Chinese
AT Chinese

    Middle East
     Jun 28, 2012

US 'dangerously short-sighted' on Yemen

WASHINGTON - As President Barack Obama's administration becomes further enmeshed in what many are calling an undeclared war in Yemen, observers here are urging the government to broaden its policy approach to the country beyond counter-terrorism.

"This is not a state that has failed, but rather a state that faces considerable challenges and the time left to work with Yemen on starting to turn this around is limited," Barbara Bodine, a former US ambassador to Yemen, said. "It will take the international community and specifically the United States having a much broader focus of where we are putting our assistance. It needs to be broader and longer term, focused far more on stability and sustainability challenges rather than focusing solely on the


security challenges."

Bodine, speaking on Tuesday at a panel discussion organized by the National Council on US-Arab Relations, said that over a half-century of relations, the US has never decided on what sort of relationship it wants with Yemen.

Today, Yemen's 26 million people find themselves saddled with an unemployment rate of nearly 40%, still higher among the youth. One of the poorest countries in the region despite its oil-dependent economy, Yemen last week was singled out by several humanitarian groups warning that 40% of the country's children are on the edge of chronic malnutrition, the second highest such rate in the world.

Over the decades, "US attention and assistance has waxed and waned, buffeted by events that have often had very little bearing on Yemen itself," Bodine said.

"Our economic assistance swings wildly, our military assistance has been very erratic, and our diplomatic rhetoric towards Yemen has also been inconsistent. Beyond cliched incantations of current policy dynamics " and the most current is, of course, counter-terrorism "the US has had a hard time finding why and whether we need to be there".

On Monday, a group of Washington policy analysts, including Bodine, sent an open letter to Obama, noting that "A broader approach that places emphasis on the underlying economic and political problems will better serve the stability of Yemen and, accordingly, (US) national security interests, rather than a primary focus on counter-terrorism efforts and direct military involvement."

It continues: "The US should recalibrate its economic and governance assistance so that it represents a greater proportion of overall assistance compared with military and security assistance. The US needs to ensure that its focus is on achieving long-term goals, not only short-term objectives."

To a great extent, the United States' short-term, invariably security-focused approach to Yemen has been epitomized by the Obama administration's ratcheting-up of drone strikes in Yemen over the past four months. Their aim is Al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula (AQAP), the Yemeni wing of the terror network.

On Monday, a US drone reportedly killed three AQAP members near the southern port of Aden. The strikes were the first time the United States has launched attacks in the province and constituted the 24th drone assault in Yemen this year, according to the Long War Journal, a reputed blog focused on the "war on terror".

According to the same source, this is more than the 23 such attacks in Pakistan this year, despite the latter having received far more coverage and public criticism.

Yet much as in Pakistan, the public's strengthening resentment at drone strikes "particularly the killing of civilians" in Yemen suggests to many that the consequences of such attacks are outweighing the benefits.

The open letter to Obama also highlights this issue, urging the US government to "Re-evaluate [the] strategy of drone strikes with the recognition that this approach is generating significant anti-American sentiment and could strengthen the appeal of extremist groups."

Indeed, AQAP has reportedly tripled in size since drone strikes in Yemen began in 2009.

Those attacks have been ramped up particularly since this February, when the country's new president, Abd Rabbuh Mansur al-Hadi, took over power. That event was a major turning point in the country's tenuous and ongoing transition from the three-and-a-half-decade rule of Ali Abdullah Saleh.

"What's happening is that both President Hadi and President Obama are getting rather deep into a mutually dependent relationship," Gregory Johnsen, a Yemen scholar at Princeton University and another signatory to the open letter, said on Tuesday.

When Hadi came to power, Johnsen says, he did not have a very deep support base in Yemen, and hence needed significant support from the US and the international community. At the same time, the US needs Hadi in order to continue its targeting of AQAP.

"Despite everything that President Obama and his staff has attempted to do, I think it finds itself in real danger of being in exactly the position today that it wanted to avoid in 2009" that is, being in an open-ended conflict in Yemen against Al-Qaeda with no real way of knowing whether it's winning, Johnsen says.

"In fact, if you look at certain barometers, it seems that the more it tries, the more it is sucked deeper into this quicksand."

Last week, for the first time, Obama admitted in a letter to congress that the US military had carried out "a limited number" of strikes against AQAP. Beyond this, however, there has been almost no officially confirmed information on what is increasingly looking like a full-blown war in Yemen.

"If this war is worth waging, it's worth waging openly. And it's worth having a strategy with a clearly defined, achievable goal," argue commentators Spencer Ackerman and Noah Shachtman in a recent essay for the Danger Room blog.

"Does anyone know what that is in Yemen? Is it the end of al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula? The containment of AQAP? A functional Yemeni government that can fight AQAP without US aid? We've gotten so used to fighting in the shadows for so long, we barely even ask our leadership what victory looks like."

(Inter Press Service)

Yemen's problems run deeper than security
(Jun 27, '12)

Yemen's new leader: another Sadat? (Mar 1, '12)

Stimulus fix to the death

2. The Israeli endgame in Iran

3. Syria and Turkey's phantom war

4. China's addiction to birth planning

5. Napoleon's march on Russia: Do dictators always fail?

6. 'Highest' building defies China bubble

7. Silver lining in Iran nuclear talks

8. Syria puts double whammy on Turkey

9. Magic and the machine

10. No way home for Myanmar's Rohingya

(24 hours to 11:59pm ET, Jun 26, 2012)


All material on this website is copyright and may not be republished in any form without written permission.
Copyright 1999 - 2012 Asia Times Online (Holdings), Ltd.
Head Office: Unit B, 16/F, Li Dong Building, No. 9 Li Yuen Street East, Central, Hong Kong
Thailand Bureau: 11/13 Petchkasem Road, Hua Hin, Prachuab Kirikhan, Thailand 77110