South Asia

Himachal Pradesh: A litmus test for India
By Swaraj Thapa

SHIMLA, India - Indian Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee is keenly aware that the future of his pro-Hindu Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) depends heavily on the outcome of provincial elections due to be held on Wednesday in northern Himachal Pradesh state. Also watching the elections with some apprehension is arch political rival Sonia Gandhi, who leads the opposition Congress party.

Little wonder then that India's two top political figures braved snow and biting cold weather in this Himalayan state, called the fruit bowl of India for its generally horticulture-friendly climate, to personally lead one of the most acrimonious election campaigns in recent history.

Three other states - Nagaland, Meghalaya and Tripura - are also due to elect new assemblies on Wednesday. But unlike Himachal Pradesh, they are situated in India's remote northeast and outcomes there do not impinge greatly on national politics.

Gandhi took the BJP head on, accusing the party of coming to power and maintaining it by "spreading communal poison" throughout her whistle-stop tour of the state last week. She also used the opportunity to expose the massive scams that have dogged the Vajpayee government, including fraud in a government-run mutual fund which resulted in millions of investors losing their life-time savings, kickbacks on defense deals and the slow pace of privatization of public sector assets.

"When the BJP talks about corruption it seems like a big joke," Gandhi said, referring to attempts by Vajpayee to bring up during his campaign earlier scams for which the Congress party, including Gandhi's late husband and former prime minister Rajiv Gandhi, paid dearly.

The Congress party, which led India to independence from British colonial rule in 1947 and has ruled for most of the succeeding years, has been out of national power since the 1996 general elections but now controls 15 state governments. However, the Congress party's winning spree in state elections was rudely interrupted by elections in western Gujarat state in December, when the BJP struck back by polarizing votes between majority Hindus and minority Muslims and swept two-thirds of the seats.

Himachal Pradesh now presents an opportunity for the Congress party to prove its theory that the Gujarat results were a mere aberration and Gandhi's oft-repeated contention that the Congress party is the "natural party of governance" in India.

Undoubtedly, a victory in Himachal Pradesh would go a long way in reinforcing the beliefs of the Congress party and Gandhi and enthuse the party in provincial elections, which are due to be held towards the end of the year in the important states of central Madhya Pradesh, western Rajasthan and Delhi, which houses the national capital.

For the BJP, losing Himachal Pradesh, one of the few states it rules, could worsen growing disenchantment with a new and aggressive brand of Hindutva (pro-Hindu) that is being promoted by groups that are closely associated with the BJP.

That both parties were well aware of the significance of Himachal Pradesh was apparent from the high-pitched political campaign that each side unleashed on the other. For the first time in this otherwise "small" state, a flurry of leaders, apart from Vajpayee and Gandhi, criss-crossed the mountainous territory in helicopters, addressing as many six rallies in a day.

In addition to Vajpayee, the BJP fielded deputy Prime Minister Lal Krishna Advani, a Hindutva hawk widely billed as Vajpayee's successor. Significantly, Hindutva was seldom an election theme in Himachal Pradesh, an overwhelmingly Hindu-majority state. Rather, the BJP campaigners have sought shrewdly to center the campaign around a "more-Hindu-than-the-Congress" plank.

Elections analysts have said that this is the strategy that worked in Gujarat, where the Congress party disastrously experimented with a "soft Hindutva" approach in place of its traditionally secular stance.

Vajpayee also used his electoral rallies to reaffirm the BJP's stand on the emotional issue of constructing a grand temple to the Hindu deity Ram at his supposed birthplace 10,000 years ago, in Ayodhya in adjacent Uttar Pradesh state.

He also went to great lengths to deny publicly that he was fond of beef hamburgers, a charge leveled against him by Congress party leaders in an attempt to demolish his Hindutva credentials. Beef is taboo for Hindus and Vajpayee has promised that his government will soon pass legislation to ban the slaughter of cows, regarded as sacred, in every corner of the country.

Gandhi personally preferred to stick to development issues. At her main rally in Shimla, she dished out dire statistics on unemployment in the state - 1.1 million jobless out of a population of 4 million.

Officials, off the record, concede that the figure may be exaggerated. But the BJP has been caught off guard by the Congress' campaign, and has been forced to do a lot of explaining rather than harp on Hindutva issues.

The BJP also faces an "anti-incumbency factor" in the state, which has been made worse by allegations of corruption leveled against chief minister Prem Kumar Dhumal and his administration.

(Inter Press Service)
 
Feb 27, 2003





Once again, showdown over Ayodhya (Feb 26, '03)

 

 

 

Affiliates
Click here to be one)

 

 
   
         
No material from Asia Times Online may be republished in any form without written permission.
Copyright Asia Times Online, 6306 The Center, Queen’s Road, Central, Hong Kong.