South Asia

Payback time for Musharraf
By Nadeem Malik

ISLAMABAD - Pakistan has gained substantially in terms of its economy since it joined the US-led "war against terrorism", with rapid growth in foreign exchange earnings, the manufacturing sector and tax revenues.

The Gross Domestic Product (GDP) is expected to rise by more than 4.5 percent during the current fiscal year ending June 2003, and latest forecasts project a 5-5.5 percent growth rate during the next two fiscals. The rate of inflation is stable at below 4 percent, with little threat of any dramatic rise. The budget deficit is also likely to be contained within the announced benchmark of 4.6 percent of GDP.

The turnaround started soon after September 11, 2001. Large external flows of new concessional multilateral loans, re-profiling of the entire official bilateral external stock of debt and one-off budgetary grants helped build coffers to the tune of $10.5 billion. The current account, which was in a historical deficit, posted a surplus of $2.22 billion last year (July-June 2001-02), and $4.38 billion until April 2003. Even if official transfers, including the Saudi Oil Facility (SOF), are excluded, the current account balance was in surplus by $2.56 billion this year, as compared to $1.014 billion in the corresponding period of the last fiscal.

The State Bank of Pakistan made large outright purchases of dollars of almost $10 billion in recent years to accumulate these reserves. Growing inflows sent by overseas workers through official banking channels provided this window of opportunity. Remittances during the July-April period were about $3.2 billion, which the government hoped would cross $4 billion mark during the year.

Foreign Direct Investment has also trickled in, with a $658 million total in 10 months. At least one major private sector bank, United Bank Limited, has been sold during this difficult period. Portfolio investment is also in the positive column after a long time, showing an over bullish trend in the market that has taken the KSE-100 Share Index to all-time highs.

There were genuine reasons to be skeptical about this positive trend in the external sector. Many believe that it was due to one-off factors and would not be sustainable. However, recent signs of growth in the real economy are more promising. "There are indications suggesting that the growth was broad based," said Nawid Hamid, senior economist of the Asian Development Bank. He maintained that industrial sector activity, agriculture growth and trends of international trade all support this assessment.

The large-scale manufacturing sector (LSM), according to official data of the Ministry of Industries, registered an average growth of 11.71 percent during July-March period of the current fiscal. The growth rate registered in the third quarter (January-March) was the highest, at 15.38 percent, as against 10.39 percent during second quarter (October-December) and 5.11 percent during the first quarter of 2002-03.

A new wave of car leasing and auto-cash facilities offered by commercial banks, awash with liquidity, along with new consumer finance schemes, has provided new impetus. However, the textile, cement and sugar industries have also shown buoyancy. The production of cement during this period was up by 20 percent, sugar grew by 12 percent and cotton cloth by 13 percent. With textiles having 19.1 percent weightage in the LSM basket, followed by 8.6 percent of sugar and 1.9 percent of cement, the overall growth rate has been dramatic.

The consumer goods industry, like deep freezers, refrigerators and TVs, and the auto industry, including cars (52 percent), motorcycles (33 percent), light commercial vehicles (58 percent), buses (42 percent), trucks (118 percent) and tractors (17 percent) have all shown robust performances in this period.

As a result of the higher economic activity, the Central Board of Revenue collected about Rs 310 billion (US$5.3 billion) in taxes during July-March 2002-03, registering an increase of 15 percent over the corresponding period of the previous fiscal. The board needs to collect another Rs 149 billion in the last quarter of the current financial year to meet its annual target of Rs 460 billion, which it is sure to do. The revenue generation will also mean that the budget deficit will remain within limits.

Exports during the period under review totaled $7.86 billion, as compared to $6.53 billion in the corresponding period of the last fiscal year, registering a record increase of 20.4 percent. Mainly textile manufactures, ready-made garments, knitwear and bed wear were exported during this period. Imports during the first three quarters increased at an even higher pace of 22.8 percent, from $7.3 billion of the last year to about $9 billion during the current fiscal year. This includes 37 percent higher machinery imports, which the government claimed was a reflection of increased industrial, manufacturing and investment activity in the country.

On the trade account, the facility granted by the European Union in response to Pakistan's support against the Taliban and al-Qaeda helped a lot, as the textile sector results show. However, the United States has not offered much in terms of trade concessions. Only a $142 million additional quota was granted over a three-year period. Pakistan's exports to the US increased from $2.25 billion in the year 2001 to $2.3 billion in 2002. At the same time, imports from the US increased from $542 million to $693.8 million.

However, US support for Pakistan within the multilateral institutions, as well as bilateral debt relief, helped Pakistan reduce its debt-servicing burden from 66 percent of budgetary revenues in 1999-2000 to 46 percent in 2002-03. The US recently provided Pakistan $188 million under the Economic Support Fund (ESF) to help buy down the $1 billion bilateral loan that Islamabad owed to Washington. US budget proposals for 2004 also indicated $395 million in new commitments, including $200 million under the ESF to help reduce the debt burden further.

However, Islamabad had made an official request to the US to waive the remaining stock of $1.8 billion debt in recognition of Islamabad's support against terrorism. Pakistan has helped catch and extradite almost 450 terrorists during the past 18 months, including Khalid Sheikh Mohammad and Abu Zubaida.

A senior official at the Ministry of Finance said that Pakistan was also seeking continued support in the issue of market access, and sales of defense articles from the US during 2004. This issue, he said, would be discussed in detail with Richard Armitage, US Deputy Secretary of State, who arrived in Pakistan on Wednesday "to promote peace and stability in the South Asia region".

One of the primary agenda items of Armitage's visit is to help facilitate dialogue between India and Pakistan ahead of President General Pervez Musharraf's visit to Washington in June 2003. Musharraf is due to meet President George W Bush to seek further economic assistance, investment and trade guarantees, and military cooperation in the fight against terrorism.

The timing of his visit is also crucial for Musharraf's personal political standing. Opposition parties have refused to accept a president in uniform, and the wide powers he still retains, including the discretion to dismiss the elected assemblies and the prime minister.

However, many diplomatic observes believe that it is time for Musharraf to concede more to the US to pave the way for better Pakistan-India relations, a process that has been revitalized in the past few weeks with the planned resumption of air, rail road and diplomatic links. Islamabad has also added 78 more items to the tradable list under the South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation.

For fully-successful ties, though, much will depend on concessions granted on the issue of Kashmir, and the Line of Control (LoC) that divides the disputed Himalayan region between the two countries. In this regard, Musharraf's summit meeting with Bush could hold the key.

(©2003 Asia Times Online Co, Ltd. All rights reserved. Please contact content@atimes.com for information on our sales and syndication policies.)
 
May 10, 2003



New start, new ideas and new faces
(May 9, '03)

US and India: A dangerous alliance
(May 9, '03)

Pakistan takes a different tack
(Apr 25, '02)

 

Affiliates
Click here to be one)

 

 
   
         
No material from Asia Times Online may be republished in any form without written permission.
Copyright Asia Times Online, 6306 The Center, Queen’s Road, Central, Hong Kong.