Search Asia Times

Advanced Search

 
South Asia

Nepal on top of the world
By Dhruba Adhikary

KATHMANDU - The world's highest mountain is Nepal's prized possession, and a part of her identity. To Buddhists, this country in the Himalaya was the birthplace of the messenger of peace; and, ironically, to the people in the war business in Britain, India and elsewhere, this place is the homeland of their legendary Gurkhas.

Nepalis call the 8,848-meter high snow-capped mountain Sagarmatha, the forehead on the sky, while the rest of the world has recognized it as Everest since 1865 when it was named after the British surveyor who measured its height, 29,028 feet. To the people in Tibet, this highest point on earth has remained Qomolungma, the goddess mother of earth, though the rulers in China have given it a different variant, Zhumulangma.

But climbers are not bothered by such disputes over nomenclature. They continue to be fascinated by the beauty of this and the country's other mountains, and are thankful for the endless chances of adventure that they provide.

Nepal's Ministry of Tourism has issued permits for 25 expeditions to Everest this year, allowing 201 individuals to apply their mountaineering skills to the supreme challenge that Everest offers. And already, several teams, including Tibetans, Chinese, Indians and Japanese (the latter team included the oldest climber ever to reach the top, aged 70) , have set their feet on the roof of the world. The successful ones are expected to return to the capital Kathmandu to take part in a week of celebrations being hosted to commemorate the first ascent on Everest 50 years ago on May 29, 1953.

Edmund Hillary of New Zealand and Sherpa Tenzing Norgay of Nepal were the first summiteers from the British expedition led by John Hunt. Release of the news about that historic ascent was deliberately delayed so that it could reach London on the eve of Queen Elizabeth's coronation on June 2.

Tenzing Norgay passed away in 1986, while Sir Edmund Hillary, 83, is traveling the world to mark the anniversary before going to Nepal. The president of the Nepal Mountaineering Association, Ang Tshering Sherpa, is trying to bring three surviving Sherpas of the expedition of the first ascent from the Everest region to be with Hillary and others in Kathmandu.

"I love the great cold mountains of the Himalaya - but it's the Sherpas that surround them with warmth and friendship," said Sir Edmund at the launching of the book Sagarmatha in 1992. That perhaps is the reason why the acclaimed mountaineer has preferred Nepal to the United Kingdom for taking part in events organized to mark the occasion.

Hillary's affection for Sherpas has been matched by the charity works his Himalayan Trust has been doing in the villages of the Everest region for the past several years. Of over 1,200 successful Everest summiteers, nearly 500 (200 of them foreigners) are expected to be in Kathmandu over the next week.

This is the first such jamboree of its kind and and it has taken on national importance. Even agitating political parties have decided to halt their anti-king demonstrations for a full week while Maoists, who are currently engaged in peace talks, are also unlikely to sabotage the tourism itinerary approved for the last week of May.

Programs in Kathmandu include a public felicitation of renowned climbers such as Hillary, Junko Tabei, first woman to reach the top of the world (1975), Reinhold Messner, the first person to climb Everest without oxygen cylinders (1978) and Appa Sherpa, who has been to the top 12 times.

A horse-drawn carriage will take the famous mountaineers through the streets of Kathmandu. "The idea is to recreate the enthusiastic scenes of 1953," said Kuber Sharma, Nepal's tourism minister. According to Sharma, the gala dinner scheduled for May 29 will be graced by King Gyanenedra. Mountaineers are also to be honored with gifts and souvenirs.

A visit to the mountaineering memorial park in Kakani, on the northern outskirts of the bowl-shaped Kathmandu valley, is also listed on the official program. The government has released a modest budget, said an official, to organize some of the activities drawn for the Golden jubilee. All Everest summiteers will be given fee-free visas, together with an undertaking to give them a 50 percent discount on visa fees when they visit Nepal for non-mountaineering purposes.

Western alpine experts often identify Everest as the "mountain without mercy" in view of the number of lives lost there. According to Elizabeth Hawley, a Kathmandu-based US chronicler of mountaineering activities in Nepal, around 175 people have lost their lives trying reach the mountain's summit. But Everest still remains every climber's dream. Nepali authorities maintain that while government as well as non-government agencies do make efforts to rescue climbers from bad weather and other unforeseen emergencies, it needs to be understood that some of the deaths in Everest are inevitable, and unavoidable.

And mountaineers themselves are aware of the element of risk involved in such expeditions. In May 1996, eight climbers lost their lives when a freak blizzard pummeled the mountain with shrieking winds and blinding snow. The Nepal government was criticized for not doing enough for climbers' safety.

Although China has reservations about the naming of the world's highest mountain, authorities in Beijing, however, do recognize the fact that the first ascent to the peak took place 50 years ago. CCTV, the Chinese television network, began telling its audience worldwide since May 16 that the final movements of a Chinese expedition members to Qomolangma from the Tibetan side would be telecast live - a technological feat for CCTV.

While reporting this event, the CCTV specifically mentioned that the expedition was launched to commemorate the human achievement made in 1953. Not only that, China is one of the 40 countries from where climbers are coming to Kathmandu to be a part of the jamboree for mountaineers.

Last year, Nepal's exchequer collected 140 million rupees (US$3 million) as direct revenue from the issuance of permits to climbers planning to scale peaks of varying altitudes. This year, which is a special year, the figures are expected to go up substantially. The royalty rates for Everest are obviously higher than for any other Himalayan peaks. It is $70,000 for a team of seven persons. A team is allowed to take up to five additional persons by paying $10,000 each.

"Money received in the form of royalties is significant," said Shankar Koirala, a senior official in the Ministry of Tourism, "but what is more important is the money the mountaineers [and trekkers] spend while they stay in Nepal." One needs to multiply, he claimed, the royalty figures by the digit seven to get an idea of total gains accrued through employment and a variety of taxes and fees.

Commercialization of mountaineering, especially of Everest, has been a critical issue for some time. Concerns expressed by personalities such as Hillary are genuine and are usually based on reports of pollution and accidents. "Everest has become a junk heap overloaded with multitudes of expeditions and their refuge," said Hillary, a former New Zealand ambassador to Nepal, in 1996. "I like to think of Everest as a great mountaineering challenge," The Guardian newspaper quoted him as saying as recently as March this year. A number of companies take inexperienced climbers to the top for fees ranging up to $50,000 per person.

Concerns for the cleanliness of mountains are understandable, said Koirala, adding that his ministry has made arrangements for cleaning campaigns at regular intervals. Besides, expedition members are required to make sure that they do not leave behind used items such as bottles, boxes and cylinders. Some of the criticism on so-called commercialization is related to royalties, which appear exorbitant when compared to the rates offered for the highest peak on the Chinese [Tibetan] side. "The crucial thing is that mountaineers themselves are not satisfied till they scale Everest from the southern face," said Koirala, alluding to the recognition attached to the feat accomplished from the Nepali side.

One strong contention in favor of keeping mountains open to visitors is based on the assumption that like rivers and forests, snow-clad mountains are Nepal's renewable resources. "These resources should be put to use and converted into a perennial source of income and economic activities," said Madhab Prasad Khanal, a retired government official who has had experience of working with the tourism ministry. Let ecological balance be maintained, and let there be a reliable arrangement for pollution control, Khanal added as a caveat.

But there are people who do not share Khanal's views. "I'm opposed to the policy of royalties-based commercialization of mountains," said Tek Chandra Pokharel, a prominent personality in the tourism business. Nepal, he argued, has set a bad precedent, which is now being adopted by countries like India and Pakistan.

With the adoption of a liberal policy in recent years, the tourism ministry has opened 276 peaks to climbers and trekkers. ( 33 of them of up to 6,600 meters high are handled by the Nepal Mountaineering Association). But only about 30 mountains are chosen by potential climbers for their activities.

Mountaineering and trekking are just one segment of tourism, though. "Our belief is that next week's mega-event will help increase the number of affluent Western tourists willing to visit and re-visit Nepal for rest and recreation purposes," said Tek Bahadur Dangi, chief executive officer of the Nepal Tourism Board, a government sector agency responsible for promoting tourism.

(Copyright 2003 Asia Times Online Co, Ltd. All rights reserved. Please contact content@atimes.com for information on our sales and syndication policies.)
 
May 24, 2003



 

Affiliates
Click here to be one)

 

 
   
         
No material from Asia Times Online may be republished in any form without written permission.
Copyright Asia Times Online, 6306 The Center, Queen¡¦s Road, Central, Hong Kong.