Search Asia Times

Advanced Search

 
South Asia

Pakistan wary of growing China-India ties
By Miriam Kagan

WASHINGTON - As Chinese and Indian officials basked in a display of improved relations this week - Beijing hosted a meeting on agricultural cooperation and the countries held first-ever joint naval exercises - Chinese officials rushed to calm Pakistani apprehensions about the growing closeness of the South Asian giants.

The traditionally frosty relationship between China and India - a result of a decades-old border dispute and India's welcoming of the Dalai Lama (the spiritual leader of Buddhism exiled from Tibet by China in the 1950s)- began to warm with a state visit by Indian Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee to China in June.

It thawed further with this week's "The Dragon and the Elephant - Rural Development and Agricultural Reform Experiences in China and India", a conference organized by the Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences and the Washington-based International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI). The meeting brought together scientists, policymakers and researchers from the two nations to learn from one another and explore avenues of cooperation in agricultural matters.

"China and India are two of the world's biggest players in the global economy, and are projected to show continued, strong economic growth in the coming decades," said IFPRI director general Joachim von Braun in the conference opening statement. "Yet they are also home to almost half the world's poor. Working to reduce poverty and malnutrition in these countries should be a primary focus," he added.

Both China and India have shown strong recent economic growth. A study by Goldman-Sachs predicts China will overtake Germany in economic output by 2008, Japan by 2015 and the United States by 2040. The same study predicts India will overtake Germany's output by 2023 and that of Japan by 2033.

Indo-China trade has also grown substantially. In 2002, bilateral trade was valued at US$5 billion. It is expected to grow to $8 billion this year. The rapid growth has created an income gap between urban dwellers and rural residents, particularly in China.

In his statement, von Braun suggested that gap could be lessened. "This can be done through investment in infrastructure, information technology and innovative institutions. The poverty and growth problem of rural areas cannot just be addressed in rural areas, but through a strategy of improved economy-wide linkages. The backbone of rural growth, however, is agriculture," he added. Conference participants will spend the next year working together to evaluate past programs and search for common solutions.

In a further sign of improving relations, China and India have conducted a first-ever joint naval exercise off the coast of Shanghai. According to the Associated Press, Chinese foreign ministry spokesman Lia Jianchao told reporters the exercises were meant to "further enhance relations and improve further understanding between the two sides".

China's traditional ally Pakistan has watched the improvement in relations with apprehension. Vajpayee's June visit was immediately followed by a trip to Beijing by Pakistan President General Pervez Musharraf. During Musharraf's visit, the two countries signed deals, including a preferential trade agreement and a promise to cooperate against Muslim separatists in China's Northwestern Xinjiang province.

Pakistani officials are worried that better relations between China and India might work against Pakistan in its own disputes with India, including over the Kashmir border area and on water rights. So Chinese officials rushed to reassure Pakistan. As the naval exercises continued, Chinese officials met with Pakistan's deputy defense minister for talks on expanding military equipment purchases; China is Pakistan's main arms supplier. "China has normal state-to-state relations with Pakistan, and this exercise will not affect relations with Pakistan," Liu told reporters.

According to Robert LaPorte Jr of Pennsylvania State University, Pakistan should not be threatened by warming relations between Indian and China. LaPorte told IPS that China and Pakistan are so strategically intertwined, it would not be in Beijing's interest to alienate its nuclear, Muslim neighbor. China understands that Pakistan's participation will be essential to the region's development, he added.

LaPorte noted that Pakistan is the only Muslim nuclear power bordering Asia and the Middle East. Alienating Pakistan could mean pushing the nation into the arms of Muslim fundamentalists, a future both China and India, who struggle with religious divisions at home, are eager to avoid.

(Inter Press Service)
 
Nov 19, 2003




India frets as China and Pakistan embrace (Nov 8, '03)

India's Dragon delusions (Oct 17, '03)

 

     
         
No material from Asia Times Online may be republished in any form without written permission.
Copyright 2003, Asia Times Online, 4305 Far East Finance Centre, 16 Harcourt Rd, Central, Hong Kong