Search Asia Times

Advanced Search

 
South Asia

Pakistan-India: Same game, new rules
By Syed Saleem Shahzad

KARACHI - A ceasefire between Pakistan and India along three of their borders went into effect at midnight on Tuesday. The million-dollar question everyone is asking, though, is how long this United States-sponsored initiative will last. The answer, it appears, is not long.

The ceasefire agreement covers the India-Pakistan international border, the Line of Control (LoC) that divides the those sections of Kashmir administered by the two countries, and along the Actual Ground Position Line in the Siachen Glacier.

Developments leading up to the ceasefire actually started several weeks ago when, under immense US pressure, Pakistan's Inter-Services-Intelligence (ISI) shut down its "Forward Section 23" in Pakistan's Azad (Free) Kashmir, which meant the closure of all training camps and ISI operations offices in that region.

Not only this, but also under US pressure, Pakistan was asked to provide access to its national data base and records of those involved in terror activities, which, according to the US definition, includes militancy in the name of jihad. For this purpose, a special wing was established in the Federal Investigation Agency of Pakistan (FIA), which normally handles matters related to white-collar crime.

This special investigation cell is jointly headed by Fareed Nawaz of the FIA and a member of the US Federal Bureau of Investigation. This is a clandestine operation to fight terror, and information relating to it has been obtained by Asia Times Online, it has not been officially disclosed.

The cell has the mandate to compile records of those involved in terror activities, collect their fingerprints and other details, and then enter the data into a mainframe system connected to all FBI offices and US immigration facilities world-wide. As a result of this operation, banned militant outfits that had resumed operations under another name were re-banned, and a number of activists arrested. This time there was a difference, though. The entire records of all suspects and organizations were seized for entry into the "terror database".

According to sources close to the Pakistani administration, the US leaned heavily on the Pakistani leadership to force the ISI to abandon its Kashmir operations in mid-stream. Just recently, a new recruitment campaign for militants - to be used in cross-border raids into Indian-administered Kashmir - was started in all big cities. And militant organizations were given huge funds to mobilize their activists and attract new recruits.

And, it is said, President General Pervez Musharraf held meetings with jihadi leaders in which he assured them that he supported "jihad in Kashmir" with his "heart and soul". After these assurances, the Jamaatut Dawa (formerly the Lashkar-i-Toiba) was encouraged, with all means and resources, to stage a large gathering in Mureedkey, Punjab, where thousands of jihadis gathered and vowed to liberate Kashmir. Maulana Masood Azhar of the Khuddamul Islam (effectively the Jaish-i-Mohammed) was also invited to address the gathering.

Before that gathering, Azhar paid frequent visits to the port city of Karachi to revive 32 units out of about 148 that had existed until the Jaish-i-Mohammed was banned. Before the last visit, a big publicity campaign started, with about Rs 50,000 (US$870) paid for wall posters alone. Subsequently, Azhar attracted about 7,000 people to north Karachi's famous Batha mosque. Azhar was visibly protected by local police.

At this point, a big operation in Kashmir appeared imminent in which it was hoped to force the Indian leadership to resume dialogue on the disputed territory on Pakistan's terms. Delhi, however, responded by applying all its good offices with Washington. As a result, the ISI's Mumbai connection, Indian underworld boss Dawood Ibrahim, was declared a "global terrorist" by the US, and the ISI took the decision to close its base operations in Kashmir. The US even said that Dawood resided in Karachi, although he has not been seen there for some time.

And then, with the US beginning a new round of pro-Indian posturing, Pakistan committed itself to a change in its mode of operations. Traditionally, jihadis have penetrated into Indian territory from Kashmir, but now the "launching" apparatus has been moved to Karachi for militants to cross the border from Sindh province into India, from where they will either make their way to Kashmir or seek out soft targets in India.

Why Pakistan cannot stop anti-Indian operations
Many thousands of Pakistanis have fought in Afghanistan (during the anti-Soviet campaign of the 1980s) and Kashmir over the past decade or more as members of jihadi outfits. After the US attacked Afghanistan in late 2001, it was largely predicted that these outfits - which are loyal to the Taliban and al-Qaeda - would rush back to lend their support, and that they would also rebel against Musharraf.

This assessment proved to be a huge misconception. The jihadi outfits were in fact a part of the ISI's operations and the brainchild of late dictator General Zia ul-Haq and General Akhtar Abdul Rehman. The purpose was to develop a para-military force that would assist the Pakistan army in the event of war. However, in the course of the 1989 uprising in Kashmir, these jihadis played so vital a role that they outdid the army, so in the 1990s it was decided that they would act as a front-line force in any India-Pakistan war.

First-hand observations by this correspondent in Azad Kashmir camps confirm that the jihadi outfits are in fact paramilitary troops. Each unit has a commander who reports to an army officer. Each jihadi commander is given funds and the brief to devise a strategy for his unit's combat operations. The commanders have lap top computers in which they store their data, from which they generate summaries of their operations for their military officers. The summaries include targets, operations and results. The jihadi commanders and army field officers always coordinate their efforts. Pro-jihadi clerics, like Mufti Nizamuddin Shamzai, are used to deliver sermons, and they are not allowed to utter a single word more than the topic on which they have been told to speak.

After September 11, 2001, ties between the army and the jihadis were at a crossroads, but they emerged as friends. Meetings were held at ISI offices in Karachi, where Shamzai and others were told the limits of their anti-US demonstrations. These clerics always abide by such guidelines. Shamzai was also taken by the ISI to North-West Frontier Province when tribals had blocked highways in support of the Taliban, and he forced them to remove all blockades.

Interestingly, some diehard jihadis with "original" thoughts came out in favor of Osama bin Laden, including Maulana Abdul Jabbar of the Jaish-i-Mohammed. Their jihadi fellows pointed this out to the ISI, which advised him against such support. When he did not give up, he was detained.

The ISI reasoned with the jihadis that they had to compromise on al-Qaeda as Pakistan did not have any strategic interests with the network. However, Pakistan did have interests with the Taliban, the ISI pointed out, so it would persuade the US to give them a role in the government in Afghanistan. In essence, then, the so-called jihadi-clerics are no more than the ISI's proxies, rather than committed "ideologues".

Major army interests in Kashmir
Apart from strategic interests, the Pakistan army has interests in the "jihad of Kashmir", from non-commissioned officers right up to the major-general who looks after Forward Section 23. It has funds to run training camps, including recruitment (Rs 10,000 for each recruit), and transportation and accommodation costs. It also has a special fund for each "mujahid" when he enters into Kashmir (Rs 20,000). Should he die, there is a special fund for compensation (Rs 50,000 in the first year and Rs 24,000 in next two years) for the bereaved family.

For Pakistan then, the ISI, the jihadis and the army are in one mind that the struggle in Kashmir will continue. All that is happening for now, under US pressure, is a shift in tactics, with Karachi becoming a center of activities. Realistically, the ceasefire along the Line of Control in Kashmir cannot therefore be expected to hold.

(Copyright 2003 Asia Times Online Co, Ltd. All rights reserved. Please contact content@atimes.com for information on our sales and syndication policies.)
 
Nov 27, 2003



The US's new man with a mission in India
(Nov 26, '03)

India: Beyond Pakistan's army and mullahs

(Nov 20, '03)

 

     
         
No material from Asia Times Online may be republished in any form without written permission.
Copyright 2003, Asia Times Online, 4305 Far East Finance Centre, 16 Harcourt Rd, Central, Hong Kong