Search Asia Times

Advanced Search

 
South Asia

Singh's economic balancing act
By Ranjit Devraj

NEW DELHI - The image that most residents of the national capital have of Manmohan Singh, due to be sworn in as India's next prime minister Saturday, is that of a diminutive, turbaned man patiently steering his small car through a chaotic sea of sleek limousines, hulking buses and slow-moving pedicabs.

That image probably portrays best the soft-spoken economist who, as finance minister between 1991 and 1996, is credited with steering India's overprotected economy - dominated by monopolistic business families and an inefficient public sector - through a difficult first phase of reforms.

"Manmohanomics" was blamed for the 1996 electoral defeat of the venerable Congress party, which had always styled itself as a pro-poor, socialist party ever since it assumed charge of the country in 1947 when India gained independence from British colonial rule. But both the left-dominated United Front government which took over in 1996 and the right-wing, ultra-nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), which followed in 1998, only deepened and widened the reforms initiated by Singh.

Now, the "Good Doctor", as the newspaper headlines often describe Singh, partly in deference to his impressive academic credentials, is back in the driver's seat - this time as prime minister after Congress party leader Sonia Gandhi declined the nomination on Wednesday.

Curiously enough, Singh's installation in the top job has been made possible by a public angered by a pro-rich reforms regime run by the outgoing BJP. The ousted ruling party harped on a "Shining India" election motto that boomeranged because the average voter felt excluded from the benefits of such reforms. Those uncharitable to the Congress party would say that its rather unexpected electoral victory in the staggered April/May elections was in fact the result of a negative vote against the BJP - rather than any endorsement of its own pro-reform, economic policies of the past.

But clearly, both Singh and the Congress party itself are creatures that now have the wisdom and hindsight of 13 years of reforms at which governments at either end of the political spectrum have had a turn at running. Moreover, the Congress party that Singh will be heading is a minority one that is heavily dependent for survival on support from the communist parties of the Left, which have emerged with more seats in parliament than ever before.

Singh, a 71-year-old Sikh who will be India's first non-Hindu prime minister, will find himself constrained by a Common Minimum Program, an outline of the economic and foreign policies of the new government, which the Left has insisted on as a condition for its crucial support. This is expected to seriously influence economic decisions in favor of farmers and the working classes. "We will bring out our Common Minimum Program in a few days in which we will lay stress on the agricultural sector, employment opportunities, industrial sector and infrastructure," Singh said while addressing his first formal press meet after being invited by President A P J Abdul Kalam to form the government on Thursday, adding that all-round development would be the key priority for the new government.

P Chidambaram, who succeeded Singh as finance minister in 1996 in the Left Front-supported United Front government - tipped for the same job again in the new government - said that communist concerns for farmers and the working classes were legitimate and could be worked out as in the past.

Not that either the Congress party or Singh need prompting on the plight of small farmers who form the backbone of India's agricultural economy, but have borne the brunt of the reform process. The phenomenon of Indian farmers committing suicide in droves has coincided with the reforms process. It is estimated that during the five years of BJP rule, at least 8,000 of them hanged themselves or consumed the deadly agricultural pesticides bought on loans that they were unable to repay.

Already, the Congress administration in Andhra Pradesh state is to introduce a relief package for families of farmers who committed suicide because of debt. The package of 150,000 rupees (US$3,300) for each affected family was announced by chief minister Y S Rajashekhar Reddy. Reddy said that nearly 3,000 farmers in the southern state had committed suicide over the past six years.

Singh says that economic reforms will continue, but with a "human face", particularly given the traumatic years India has witnessed because of a sudden shift from long years of protectionism and policies favoring self-reliance. Singh, who was born in 1932 in a rural village (Gah in what is now Pakistan), needs no lessons on the importance to the economy of taking the interests of farmers seriously. The man acknowledged as the "father of Indian reforms" criticized the last budget presented by the business-friendly BJP as "a bunch of tokenisms that refuse to address real problems like the eradication of poverty and agricultural development".

On the other hand, Singh has not hesitated to oppose a policy of providing free power to farmers, announced last week by the new Congress party provincial government in the southern state of Andhra Pradesh. The announcement was made after the defeat of the aggressively pro-reform Telugu Desam Party, a regional ally of the BJP.

In his own words, Singh said what he really wanted to do was to "release the innovative, entrepreneurial spirit which always existed in India through a credible structural adjustment program". After receiving the formal letter of invitation to form the new government from Kalam Wednesday evening, Singh pledged to build "new opportunities for the poor and downtrodden to participate in the economic process".

"No power on earth can stop an idea whose time has come. The emergence of India as a major global economic power happens to be one such idea whose time has come," he said.

Former Reserve Bank governor Bimal Jalan said Singh may be assuming office at a time when the country was facing "huge challenges" in political, economic and social spheres, however Singh was the right man to take charge of the challenges and problems the country faced today. "His past record, achievements, educational qualifications stand him in very good stead in tackling the problems we have today," he told Indian media. "Dr Singh's records and achievements are an open book. Brilliant economist, brilliant finance minister, brilliant [Reserve] bank governor, well-known internationally."

Singh, meanwhile, said that there was no question of dismantling the programs set in motion by the outgoing BJP-led National Democratic Alliance government, but it was necessary that both the private and the public sectors be equally strong. For example, there is no need to privatize nationalized banks, said Singh, adding that both the public and private enterprises should be on an equal footing and it should be ensured that the workers do not suffer as a result of any policy moves by the government. Singh said that when he had presented his budget 13 years ago as the finance minister in the P V Narasimha Rao government, he had said that India could emerge as a global power and had worked towards that. He reiterated that the new government would work "steadfastly" to carry forward the programs initiated at that time.

India Inc gives the thumbs up
India Inc is welcoming the election of Singh as prime minister, with business leaders expressing confidence that he would further the reform process, even as it praised of Gandhi for giving up the top post.

"Singh, the architect of economic reforms, would be able to carry forward the process and drive the country on higher growth trajectory," said N Srinivasan, director general of the Confederation of Indian Industry. Appreciating the decision taken by Gandhi, he said, "The stature of Sonia Gandhi has gone up tremendously by not taking the prime ministership and recommending the name of Singh, known for balance, knowledge of economy, humility, simplicity, sensitivity and ability to listen to people."

Echoing his sentiments, Associated Chambers of Commerce and Industry of India president M K Sanghi congratulated Gandhi for taking the decision as "per her conscience" and extended the total support of trade and industry to the new government for carrying the country forward. He said the chamber was hopeful that the architect of country's liberalization policies, Singh, would give further impetus to reforms particularly in the fields of agriculture, the financial sector , labor and education.

Talking about Singh's clean image, Electrolux CEO Rajeev Karwal said being the architect of liberalization, Singh would prove to be an architect of a new value system in the country. "I am sure Singh will provide India a very balanced economic leadership," he said.

India's markets have been on a roller-coaster ride since the Congress party won, with stocks plummeting 11 percent on "Black Monday", as the Mumbai exchange experienced its biggest drop in its 129-year history. Investors were concerned that any new government would only be able to rule with support from pro-labor, anti-privatization communists, which may block or slow key reforms. But investor jitters have subsided, with stocks rising following news that Singh will take the premiership, and the belief he can balance the demands of the leftists and businesspeople. "Our government recognizes the importance of a healthy capital market and there is no reason for anybody to panic," Singh told reporters late Wednesday. On Thursday markets held steady, suggesting the political uncertainty of the past week is subsiding.

(Inter Press Service, with additional information from Asia Pulse/PTI)


May 21, 2004




Win-win: Manmohan Singh gets the nod (May 20, '04)

Sonia lays down her legacy (May 20, '04)

While Sonia dallies, markets spurt (May 20, '04)

Indian foreign policy: Left foot forward (May 15, '04)

 

     
         
No material from Asia Times Online may be republished in any form without written permission.
Copyright 2003, Asia Times Online, 4305 Far East Finance Centre, 16 Harcourt Rd, Central, Hong Kong