Asia Time Online - Daily News
Asia Times Chinese
AT Chinese

    South Asia
     Sep 10, 2008
US warned over raids in Pakistan
By Gareth Porter

WASHINGTON - The National Intelligence Council (NIC), the US intelligence community's focal point for estimating future developments, warned the George W Bush administration last month that a decision to launch commando raids by US troops against al-Qaeda-related targets in Pakistan's North-West Frontier Province region would carry a high risk of further destabilizing the Pakistani military and government, according to sources familiar with the intelligence community's response to the issue.

That blunt warning was conveyed to the White House in an oral briefing by a top official of the NIC two or three weeks ago, according to Philip Giraldi, former operations officer and counter-terrorist specialist in the Central Intelligence Agency Directorate


of Operations - now known as the National Clandestine Service - who maintains contacts with the intelligence community.

Another source, who has been briefed by NIC officials on the issue, confirms the NIC message, which represents a consensus in the intelligence community, was conveyed to the Bush administration in August, just as an intense debate over whether to carry out commando raids against al-Qaeda and Taliban targets in the Federally Administered Tribal Areas (FATA) of Pakistan was still underway.

The source, who asked not to be identified because of the confidentiality of his contacts with the NIC, said the White House was warned that if US commando raids continued over a longer period of time, the NIC believes they could threaten the unity of the Pakistani military.

US special operations forces based at Bagram Air Force base in Afghanistan carried out a helicopter-borne ground raid by commandos in South Waziristan on September 3 which reportedly killed as many as 20 people, most of whom were apparently civilians. Both the New York Times and Washington Post said top officials indicated this was only the beginning of wider campaign of raids against al-Qaeda and Taliban targets in the frontier area of Pakistan.

The Pakistani government lodged a diplomatic protest over the raid, which was the first known incursion into Pakistan by US forces since the 2001 invasion of Afghanistan, and the Pakistani parliament condemned it in a resolution.

The intelligence community believes US military incursions into Pakistan will benefit political-military organizations allied with the Taliban seeking to destabilize the national government in Islamabad.

Patrick Lang, former defense intelligence officer for the Middle East at the Defense Intelligence Agency, told Inter Press Service he understands the intelligence community issued a "pretty clear warning" against the commando raid. "They said, in effect, if you want to see the Pakistani government collapse, go right ahead," Lang said.

A key to the strategy of Islamic extremists in the FATA region in northwest Pakistan is believed to be winning over troops in both the Frontier Corps, the militia recruited from the local population, and the regular Pakistani army. The Pakistani military rejected a proposal earlier this year from US military leaders for US special operations officers to train units of the Frontier Corps in counter-insurgency, along with the use of cash payments to obtain their cooperation against the Taliban and its allies.

But the intelligence community regards the Frontier Corps as already "wavering", the source familiar with NIC thinking says, and it is feared that US military raids would cause more of those units to actively support the militant Islamic organizations in the FATA.

The intelligence community's greatest fear, according to the source, is the impact of anti-US anger on the morale of the regular Pakistani army. One reason for that concern is the fact that a disproportionate percentage of the army officers serving in the region are Pashtun. The tribal population of the FATA is largely Pashtun, and if the US commando raids continue beyond a few months, analysts believe they could provoke large-scale defections from the Pakistani army serving in the FATA.

Selig Harrison of the Center for International Policy, a veteran journalist and author specializing in Pakistan affairs, agreed in an interview that the raids, along with targeted missile strikes that have caused many civilian casualties, are likely to strain the loyalties of Pashtun army officers serving in the FATA.

In an article in the International Herald Tribune in August 2007, Harrison warned that the Pashtun-based radical movement in the northwest "could lead to the unification of the estimated 41 million Pashtuns on both sides of the border, the breakup of Pakistan and Afghanistan, and the emergence of a new national entity, Pashtunistan, under radical Islamist leadership".

Although the NIC is responsible for producing national intelligence estimates, it has not been asked to provide any estimate on the potential consequences of a policy of raids by US special operations forces against targets in the FATA believed to be linked to al-Qaeda, according to the former CIA official.

Ironically, it was the July 2007 national intelligence estimate produced by the NIC on al-Qaeda that contributed to growing pressure for direct US military action in Pakistan. The conclusion of NIE that al-Qaeda enjoyed a safe haven in Pakistan which had become the primary center of its operations worldwide was highly publicized and highly charged politically.

The Pakistani military reacted to the US raid last week by warning it would provoke new attacks by militants in the frontier area. The New York Times quoted the spokesman for the Pakistani military, General Athar Abbas, as warning that the killing of civilians had created a greater risk that tribesmen who have supported the Pakistani soldiers and opposed the Taliban in the past will shift loyalties out of anger.

"Such actions are completely counterproductive and can result in huge losses, because it gives the civilians a cause to rise against the Pakistani military," Abbas was quoted as saying.

According to Pakistan's leading daily newspaper, Dawn, Pakistan's National Security Council received an intelligence report in June 2007 on the "Talibanization" of the region, which cited "the presence of foreign forces in Afghanistan" and the "growing feeling among Muslims that they are under attack" as factors contributing to the "growing insurgency" in the region.

Gareth Porter is an investigative historian and journalist specializing in US national security policy. The paperback edition of his latest book, Perils of Dominance: Imbalance of Power and the Road to War in Vietnam, was published in 2006.

(Inter Press Service)

Afghanistan's war has a new battlefield
(Aug 30,'08)

A sting in Pakistan's al-Qaeda mission (Aug 29,'08)

1. How Obama lost the election

2. Hindu gods spike Chinese dragon

3. Azerbaijan at crosswinds of a new cold war

4. US shrinks from arming Georgia

5. China still on-side with Russia

6. Militancy dogs Pakistan's new president

7. China's Paralympic possibilities

8. What Sondhi really wants for Thailand

9. The assets of penultimate fools

10. McCain stars in 'Back to the Future 08'

11. Triangulating an Asian conflict

(24 hours to 11:59pm ET, Sep 8, 2008)


All material on this website is copyright and may not be republished in any form without written permission.
Copyright 1999 - 2008 Asia Times Online (Holdings), Ltd.
Head Office: Unit B, 16/F, Li Dong Building, No. 9 Li Yuen Street East, Central, Hong Kong
Thailand Bureau: 11/13 Petchkasem Road, Hua Hin, Prachuab Kirikhan, Thailand 77110