|Pakistan fights for its tribal soul
By Syed Saleem Shahzad
KARACHI - Pakistan's month-long military operation in the Malakand Division of
North-West Frontier Province (NWFP), which includes the scene of especially
heavy fighting in the Swat Valley, has, per official figures, cost the lives of
over 1,300 militants and led to the displacement of 3.5 million civilians.
The battle is far from over.
Under relentless pressure from the United States to get the job done once and
for all, Pakistan is opening up new fronts in an attempt to wipe out Taliban
militants and the al-Qaeda "franchise" under which they operate.
On Thursday morning, the Pakistan Air Force conducted strikes in Orakzai Agency
in the Federally Administered Tribal Areas, and ground and air operations have
started in the Frontier Regions (Jani Khel - the tribal areas adjacent to the
city) of Bannu district in NWFP. Al-Qaeda's shura (council) is believed to operate from Jani
The military is also expected to move in strength into the South Waziristan
tribal area to go after a nexus that includes Pakistani Taliban leader
Baitullah Mehsud, Punjabi militants, Uzbeks and al-Qaeda. Clashes are reported
to have already taken place.
Washington has reacted positively to the Pakistani initiatives, but garrison
headquarters in Rawalpindi, the twin city of the capital Islamabad, are
nervous. The top brass are aware of the tough fight their troops have had in
Malakand Division and the resentment the operations have caused across the
Tuesday's attack on the Pearl Continental Hotel in Peshawar, the capital of
NWFP, in which 19 people, including two United Nations staff, were killed and
70 wounded, is a stark reminder of the dangers of fighting the American war in
Contacts familiar with the background to the attack told Asia Times Online it
was approved by al-Qaeda and carried out by a nexus of militants that included
Hakeemullah Mehsud of Orakzai Agency (a relative of Baitullah Mehsud), members
of the Sunni militant group Laskhar-e-Jhangvi from the town of Darra Adam Khel
in NWFP and the Omar group from the Frontier Regions of Peshawar.
In a message to Asia Times Online, a senior militant leader maintained that the
operation had also aimed to take out US Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI)
and North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) officials staying at the hotel.
They were said to be in talks with Pakistani officials to work out ways to
protect the 90% of NATO supplies for Afghanistan that pass through Peshawar.
This account, however, was disputed by Qudsia Qadri, editor-in-chief of the
Pakistani Daily Financial Post, who told Asia Times Online that she stayed in
the five-star hotel for a few days until Tuesday afternoon and she had not seen
any FBI or NATO officials.
"The occupancy of the hotel was hardly 5%. I met a few foreigners, in the gym
and at breakfast, but they were all working with NGOs [non-governmental
agencies] to help the internally displaced people of Malakand," said Qadri.
How the attack was conceived
Baitullah Mehsud, al-Qaeda members and Punjabi militants live in North
Waziristan and South Waziristan, remote regions on the border with Afghanistan
far from Khyber Agency, through which NATO supplies pass, Kurram Agency, a hub
of anti-Taliban Shi'ite forces, and Peshawar.
None of these three areas has indigenous Taliban. Therefore, Orakzai Agency,
the only tribal area that does not have a border with Afghanistan, was chosen
to station Taliban from South Waziristan and other regions.
By the beginning of this year, Orakzai Agency had been taken over by the
Taliban and declared an Islamic emirate. The amir (leader) was Moulvi
Saeed, but the public face was Hakeemullah Mehsud, a lieutenant of Baitullah
Mehsud imported from South Waziristan.
Gradually, they brought in criminal elements, including anti-Shi'ite fugitives
of the Laskhar-e-Jhangvi, and placed them in Darra Adam Khel, just on the
outskirts of Peshawar. The Omar group was assigned to the frontier regions of
Peshawar. With these groups in place, Khyber Agency and Peshawar could easily
be accessed - exactly as happened with Tuesday's hotel attack.
The Pakistani security forces are braced for similar attacks now that the
battle is being extended into South Waziristan and other tribal areas. At the
same time, ethnic and political clashes have risen to unprecedented levels in
the southern port city of Karachi, through which most of NATO's supplies enter
In the past week, over 50 people have been killed. The anti-Taliban Muttahida
Quami Movement is attributed with most of the killing in a fight against
members of a breakaway faction. Retaliation is expected in the coming days,
which could result in even heavier bloodshed. The situation could become so bad
that the military would have to intervene. The problem is, its forces are
already spread thin in the north.
For the time being, these northern areas remain the prime concern, and the
militants and al-Qaeda are ready.
Safe havens in the Hindu Kush
The Eastern Hindu Kush range, also known as the High Hindu Kush range, is
mostly located in northern Pakistan and the Nuristan and Badakhshan provinces
This chain of mountains connects with several smaller ranges, such as Spin
Ghar, the Tora Bora, the Suleman Range, Toba Kakar, and creates a natural
corridor that passes through the entire Pakistani tribal areas and the Afghan
border provinces all the way to the Pakistani coastal area in Balochistan
By 2008, al-Qaeda had taken control of the 1,500-square-kilometer corridor -
something it had planned to do since fleeing Afghanistan when the Taliban were
defeated by US-led forces in December 2001.
Al-Qaeda decided then to build a regional ideologically motivated franchise in
South Asia to thwart the strategic designs of Western powers in the area.
While US forces were vainly trying to hunt down al-Qaeda in the Tora Bora
mountains, the group was focused on establishing links with organizations such
as the Jaishul al-Qiba al-Jihadi al-Siri al-Alami and Jundallah in the
Pakistani tribal areas and organizing the recruitment of Pakistanis and Afghans
to those organizations. The underlying reason for doing this was to destroy the
local political and social structures and in their place establish an al-Qaeda
The plan worked. Today, in many parts of the Hindu Kush corridor, centuries-old
tribal systems and their connections with the Pakistani establishment through
an appointed political agent have been replaced by a system of Islamic
The old breed of tribal elders, religious clerics and tribal chiefs, loyal to
Pakistan and its systems, has been wiped out, to be replaced by warlords such
as Haji Omar, Baitullah Mehsud, (slain) Nek Mohammad and (slain) Abdullah
Mehsud. They are all al-Qaeda allies, and allow al-Qaeda freedom of movement in
their areas within the corridor.
Al-Qaeda members from abroad also use the corridor to enter the Pakistani
tribal areas. It is not always safe. Recently, security agencies arrested four
Saudi nationals in Mohmand Agency. They were named only as Ahmed, Ali, Mohammad
and Obaidullah and had arrived in Pakistan from Saudi Arabia in 2008-09 after
passing through Iran. Had they traveled through Pakistani cities towards the
tribal areas, they would most likely have been arrested much earlier.
Recently, al-Qaeda broadened its network by forging closer links with the
Pakistani-based Iranian insurgency group Jundallah, which operates from around
Turbat in Pakistan's Balochistan province.
Pakistan at a crossroads
This situation has brought Pakistan to a crossroads. Al-Qaeda has in many areas
devastated the traditional tribal systems and established its franchise in very
The country's administrative systems and law-enforcing agencies were not
designed to cope with such developments. The only response it has been able to
come up with is to mobilize the military - a controversial decision that could
There are several reasons why the militants were able to undermine the tribes.
The militant organizations are highly organized, battle-hardened, heavily armed
and well funded. And importantly, while tribal influence is limited to its own
area, its own people, the militant organizations have cross-tribal,
cross-border and international linkages. And while the tribes are bound by
their tribal traditions and customary laws (riwaj), the militant
organizations are not. They have out-gunned, out-funded and out-organized the
tribal malik (leader) and his tribe.
Pakistan had planned to prop up the tribes, as the real strength of a country
is its people. No government, whether civilian or military, can function or
succeed until it has public support behind it.
This it started doing by signing agreements with selected tribes. These
included ones with Sufi Mohammad in Malakand to prop up the administrative
system. However, international pressure - mainly from Washington - forced
Pakistan to abandon this roadmap in place of full-frontal military engagement
with the militants.
Up until the latest offensive that began in Swat and which is now being
extended, military action usually petered out after securing only temporary
success. The government of the day generally lacked the will to go for the
kill, and there remained segments within the intelligence apparatus and
military sympathetic to the militants.
It now appears the government is prepared for a long fight, but ultimately it
will have to take control of the corridor that provides the militants with the
space from which to attack, regroup and attack again.
This would have to involve stepped-up cooperation with forces in Afghanistan to
jointly patrol the border, and most importantly, a renewed attempt to revive
the tribal systems where they have been infiltrated by militants.
Individually, these are mammoth tasks, in combination almost impossible. And as
the planes and tanks roll in greater numbers across greater areas of Pakistan,
these goals risk being lost in the fog of war.
Syed Saleem Shahzad is Asia Times Online's Pakistan Bureau Chief. He can
be reached at firstname.lastname@example.org
(Copyright 2009 Asia Times Online (Holdings) Ltd. All rights reserved. Please
contact us about
sales, syndication and
All material on this
website is copyright and may not be republished in any form without written
© Copyright 1999 - 2009 Asia Times
Online (Holdings), Ltd.
Office: Unit B, 16/F, Li Dong Building, No. 9 Li Yuen Street East,
Central, Hong Kong
11/13 Petchkasem Road, Hua Hin, Prachuab Kirikhan, Thailand 77110