US tweaks its rules of engagement
By Danielle Kurtzleben
WASHINGTON - Facing a worsening security situation in Afghanistan as well as
rapidly approaching elections in that country, the Barack Obama administration
is touting a new, broad approach to winning the fight against insurgent groups
in Afghanistan and Pakistan.
Ambassador Richard Holbrooke, the US special representative to Afghanistan and
Pakistan, spoke at the Center for American Progress on Wednesday about the
civilian component to the new US approach in Afghanistan and Pakistan.
Holbrooke was joined by a panel of 10 individuals from his inter-agency team,
which represents nine agencies that are working
together on the US-Afghanistan-Pakistan civilian effort.
Holbrooke's team members represented a variety of facets of the US civilian
strategy in the region, including agriculture, governance, media and
communications, and investigations into terrorist financing.
He stressed the incremental nature of the civilian effort, pointing out that
defeat and victory are not yet relevant terms to use in terms of civil society
programs. "The payoff is still to come. We have to produce results, and we
understand that, and we're not here today to tell you we're winning or we're
losing. We're not here today to say we're optimistic or pessimistic."
"We're here to tell you that we are in this fight in a different way, with a
determination to succeed," he added.
Though several members of Holbrooke's panel stressed that the fates of
Afghanistan and Pakistan are intertwined, much of the discussion focused on
military and civilian efforts in Afghanistan.
Holbrooke explained the apparent prioritization of Afghanistan by saying that
the Taliban and al-Qaeda "are basically fighting in support of one another, so
they are allies." He also observed, "If you abandon the struggle in
Afghanistan, you will suffer against al-Qaeda as well."
The broadening of strategy comes at a particularly difficult time for US troops
in Afghanistan. July saw 40 US military casualties, the highest monthly total
yet in Afghanistan, and 18 US soldiers have been killed so far in August.
In an August 10 article in The Wall Street Journal, General Stanley McChrystal,
commander of US troops in Afghanistan, acknowledged the worsening situation
there, saying that the Taliban are threatening formerly secured areas in the
north and west, and that "US casualties are likely to remain high for months to
McChrystal is expected to report to Obama this September about the situation in
Afghanistan, at which point the decision will be made whether to send more
Much of the recent escalation of violence in Afghanistan has come from the
Taliban - in anticipation of upcoming elections, set for August 20.
The Taliban has vowed to derail the elections, urging Afghanis not to vote and
calling the election a "seductive US process".
US President Barack Obama has called the upcoming elections "the most important
event this year in Afghanistan" and both the US and the larger international
community are working to ensure that those elections go as smoothly as
Jane Marriott, a senior advisor to the special representative for Afghanistan
and Pakistan, conceded on Wednesday that the elections "are being held in very
difficult security conditions, and they won't be perfect".
Still, she said, the US was working to help the election and campaign process
along; one example Marriott cited is the US providing media capacity and
transportation to candidates, helping them to "campaign properly".
According to Rina Amiri, senior advisor on Afghanistan for the Office of the
Special Representative to Afghanistan and Pakistan, the anticipation of the
election has reached a fever pitch in Afghanistan, both among candidates and
"This is the most candidates that have competed for an election," said Amiri,
referring to the 41 presidential candidates, including two women, and the 3,300
people running for 420 seats in the provincial council elections.
She also added that 17 million Afghanis - about half of the country's
population - have registered to vote. This is up from the roughly 12 million
who registered to vote in the 2004 elections.
President Hamid Karzai is considered the leader in the pool of presidential
candidates, though recent polls suggest that he will likely not get the 50% of
the vote needed to win the presidency outright in the first round of elections.
If no candidate gets 50%, a second round of elections will be held in October.
The Obama administration and Karzai government have had an at times rocky
relationship. Karzai has criticized the US use of private contractors, and the
US has criticized Karzai's relationships with prominent Afghani warlords.
However, the Obama administration stance appears to have softened recently: the
Associated Press reported that Secretary of State Hillary Clinton this week
indicated that the US would work with whomever wins the Afghan presidential
Members of Holbrooke’s team reflected this attitude on Wednesday. Marriott
characterized the US and the international community as "actively impartial in
these elections", and Amiri told Inter Press Service, "The [US] Embassy enjoys
a good relationship with all of the candidates."
Amiri also dismissed reports of friction between the US and Karzai as being a
creation of the media - "there is a whole other reality that exists at the
press level," she said, adding, "I think all of the key candidates are showing
that they are going to be engaging on a constructive level," regardless of
Post-election, then, is when Holbrooke's team hopes to work with the government
to push its variety of programs. "After this election is settled," said
Holbrooke, "we [the international community] will be asking the government to
reinvigorate the leadership in these fields that we've heard today."
Holbrooke also remarked that, as important as all of his team's efforts are,
security is a precursor to real success on the civilian front; he noted that a
school or a bridge is useless without the security to use them.
"Of course, you can't do civilian growth unless you have security," he said.