Afghans fear infiltration from Iran
By Zia Ahmadi and Mustafa Saber
HERAT - Islam Qala, a small border town that forms the gateway between Iran and
Afghanistan, is a focus of concern for Afghan officials fighting the Taliban
insurgency because some believe Iran is using it to infiltrate guerrillas
intent on destabilizing the Kabul government.
"I was working in Iran for about eight months," said one man, a former refugee,
who spoke on condition of anonymity. "But I got an offer from the Taliban in
Gozara district [of Herat province] offering me a higher salary, so I
Once he had crossed the border into Afghanistan, he said Pakistanis and
Iranians based in the hills of Pashtun Zarghon
district, the site of a growing insurgency, gave him military training.
For four months, the man said he participated in armed attacks on behalf of the
Taliban in the Gozara and Pashtun Zarghon districts, and received a monthly
salary of 20,000-30,000 Pakistani rupees (US$240 to $360).
"We struck security posts in the villages of Toot, Siyawooshan and Injel, as
well as carrying out attacks on foreign military convoys," he said.
Now he is happily settled in civilian life, having been awarded a certificate
by the Peace and Reconciliation Commission - an Afghan body established in 2005
as a mechanism for engaging with insurgents - that records his decision to lay
down his arms.
Border police officials in Islam Qala say that more than 100 Afghans return
from Iran daily. Many lack refugee documents or other identity cards to prove
their Afghan citizenship and there is no adequate process to check them, which
leads to many undesirables passing through, they say.
"Dozens of refugees are deported from Iran every day," said Abdullah Achakzai,
a border police officer who works at the Islam Qala checkpoint. "We have caught
Arab and Iranian citizens trying to enter Afghanistan without the proper
documentation and have turned them over to the National Directorate of
Security, NDS. But we cannot check everybody so carefully. We do not have
enough officers, or the right equipment."
Officials fear that Islam Qala is being used as an infiltration point by
potential guerrillas, whether they are returning Afghans or foreign citizens
trying to conceal their identities.
"One of these refugees told us that Iranian troops at the Sang-e-Safed military
base said that Afghanistan is under American occupation," Achakzai said. "They
asked him to fight against America when he went back to Afghanistan."
Achakzai said the border police had recently stopped an Iranian citizen posing
as an Afghan refugee. "He had maps with him of Herat airport and other
documents concerning the 207th Zafar [Afghan National Army] corps."
Haji Sher Ahmad, who owns a hotel in Islam Qala, told the Institute for War and
Peace Reporting that many foreigners had stayed there recently.
"Several men who were speaking Arabic, and had apparently been deported from
Iran, came to my hotel and stayed several nights," he said. "They asked for the
best rooms, and ordered the most expensive food. I contacted the police, but
they did not do anything."
An employee of the Bamyan Chahr Fasel Hotel in Herat city said that over the
past year, several people had come to the hotel introducing themselves as
Afghan refugees returning from Iran, but were in fact speaking Arabic among
"After staying a few nights, they went off someplace," said the man, who spoke
on condition of anonymity. "We recently found a suitcase of one of the
'repatriates' that had been forgotten at the hotel. When we opened it, it was
full of maps and other documents. We gave it to the NDS."
Police officials in Herat say that many foreigners who support the insurgency
in western Afghanistan have entered the country illegally through checkpoints
like Islam Qala.
"Two Iranian citizens were arrested during a police operation against
anti-government militants in Gozara district," said Ismatullah Alizai, Herat
police chief. "We turned them over to the NDS for further investigation."
According to Alizai, more than 50 foreigners, among them Pakistanis, Chechens
and Iranians, had been identified in the Gozara and Pashtun Zarghon districts.
They are suspected of supporting the insurgency.
"Many terrorist attacks are organized by foreigners in Herat province," he
In Gozara district, which has seen a spike in insurgent activity over the past
year, residents say that two Iranian Kurdish women had been seen in Siyawooshan
"I spoke with these two women," said one Gozara resident, who spoke on
condition of anonymity. "They were over 30 years old. They told me that
Afghanistan has been invaded by America, and it is the duty of every Muslim man
and woman to devote their lives to the liberation of this Muslim land."
Parliamentarian Mohammad Daud Sultanzoy said he had seen reports indicating
that foreign militants who are cooperating with the Taliban often enter
Afghanistan posing as refugees being repatriated.
"If the Afghan border police cannot control the borders, it is undeniable that
the influence of foreigners who support the anti-government militants will
grow," he said.
He recommended that the number of border police be increased, so that no
refugee without the proper documentation would be able to enter the country.
Officials at the Iranian consulate in Herat said the country deports only
Afghans who do not have proper documentation. They dismissed any suggestion
that they were encouraging or allowing Pakistanis, Chechens or other foreign
citizens to enter Afghanistan as Afghan refugees.
But in early October, Afghan speculation about Iranian intentions was further
fueled when local people say Iran temporarily relaxed its border restrictions
and allowed hundreds of undocumented Afghans to cross the border into Iran.
According to Colonel Hamidullah Sarhadi, the quartermaster of the border police
in Herat, close to 2,000 Afghans were allowed to enter Iran during a two-day
Some Afghans fear Iran is deliberately attracting energetic young people so
that they can be indoctrinated and sent back to Afghanistan to fight the
"With the use of Afghan refugees, Iran is paving the way for opposition against
the Afghan government," said Khalil Ahmad Amiri, 30, a resident of Herat city.
But Iranian border officials deny that their frontier was opened. According to
the Iranian consulate in Herat, the country already has close to one million
registered Afghans in the country, along with another million who have entered
illegally. In past years, Iran has embarked on a campaign to expel illegal
Afghan refugees, sometimes as many as 500 per day, creating huge problems on
the Afghan side of the border.
Some Afghan commentators have poured cold water on the speculation around the
reported relaxation of border restrictions. "It is too early to say that Iran
is going to use these Afghans for military purposes," said political expert
Saeedi thinks a more subtle Iranian opposition to the United States and the
Afghan government could have been the reason behind the alleged move.
"Iran wants to show its sympathy to the Afghans, who have suffered so much as a
result of Iranian deportation. It wants to gain a political, social and
economic advantage in Afghanistan because of its opposition to the United
States," he said.
Basir Begzad, a political analyst in Herat, suggests that the reported frontier
opening was an attempt to undermine confidence in the Kabul authorities and the
international community. "They want to show the world that Afghans are not
happy with the current government and the foreign forces, and that they run
away as soon as they get the chance," he said.
Zia Ahmadi and Mustafa Saber are IWPR-trained reporters based in