Southeast Asia

How Indonesia repays Timorese loyalty
By Richel Langit

JAKARTA - They were loyal to the Indonesian flag, and were uprooted from their ancestral land in East Timor because of it. And their love for the Red and White flag has been rewarded with a squalid life in makeshift camps in West Timor and elsewhere, stripped of their rights as Indonesian citizens.

Worse still, East Timorese languishing in refugee camps in Atambua and Kupang, both in East Nusa Tenggara province, have little to eat as Jakarta has halted all humanitarian assistance to those camps, claiming budget constraints. The government has also given the refugees until August 31 to return to East Timor, where they could be victims of revenge at the hands of the victorious pro-independence population.

The Indonesian government, obviously still reeling from its humiliating defeat in the United Nations-organized referendum in East Timorese independence on August 30, 1999, has denied East Timorese scattered throughout the country the right to obtain a new national citizenship card, an identification card known locally as KTP that is valid for three to five years.

The official reason given by government officials has been that the East Timorese are refugees whose citizenship status has not yet been resolved. Some local government officials in West Timor, the home of some 40,000 refugees, had also said they did not want these East Timorese to obtain a passport for fear that they would travel to the newly declared nation of East Timor freely.

Aside from West Timor, East Timorese refugees are also found on the neighboring island of Flores, in South Sulawesi province, and in Jakarta.

The KTP, which in the 1960s and '70s served as an effective tool to control the movement of suspected leaders or followers of the now defunct Indonesian Communist Party (PKI), has become the only ID card valid throughout the country. One has to have a KTP if he or she wants to apply for a passport, withdraw money from a bank, or obtain official documents such as birth certificates from state institutions. It is issued by the subdistrict head but must bear the signature of the district head. People aged between 17 and 60 years are required to have a valid KTP always, and any negligence could result in jail or a fine determined by local authorities.

So the effect of the government's policy of not issuing new KTPs to East Timorese means they are forced them to stay in their respective camps or homes. They may move around the country but cannot travel overseas, unless their passports are still valid.

The situation is absurd. Long before the referendum in 1999, in which close to 80 percent of some 450,000 East Timorese who had voting rights chose to part ways with Indonesia, these East Timorese were Indonesian citizens and had valid KTPs and other official documents.

East Timorese refugees, whose number reached more than 250,000 at the height of the East Timor crisis in 1999, fled to West Timor and other islands because they knew they were legally Indonesians with valid Indonesian KTPs. Some of them, notably those who had access to power during Indonesia's brutal occupation from 1975 to 1999, had legitimate and valid Indonesian passports.

There is no doubt that East Timorese still living in refugee camps in West Timor campaigned for the former Portuguese colony's integration into Indonesia in 1999, knowing very well that they could be easy targets for revenge by pro-independence people who dominated the province. They chose to stay in Indonesia partly because they loved the country.

So, despite the change in East Timor's political status, East Timorese refugees are still legitimate Indonesians and will remain to be so as long as they don't renounce their Indonesian citizenship. As such, the Indonesian government has no valid reason to deny East Timorese the right to obtain a new KTP and other official documents. That Jakarta suffered a shameful defeat in 1999 does not justify the revocation of citizenship by the Indonesian government.

It would seem that the Indonesian authorities are still unable to come to terms with the reality that East Timor, which Indonesia annexed in 1976 as its 27th province, had broken away from the country and become a fully independent state.

This resentment was obvious when politicians and lawmakers in the House of Representatives reacted angrily to President Megawati Sukarnoputri's decision to witness the official declaration of East Timor's independence early on May 20. Some legislators even went as far as submitting a petition to House leaders to have Megawati explain her visit to East Timor before the legislature.

East Timorese refugees were mostly herded into makeshift refugee camps in West Timor with the idea that they would have a better life as Indonesians rather than as citizens of East Timor, a tiny country with poor resources. They were also duped into believing that the Indonesian government would always support them.

Thousands of East Timorese refugees have picketed the office of the East Nusa Tenggara governor, demanding that the government resume humanitarian assistance to numerous refugee camps in Atambua and Kupang. All of them have been turned away empty-handed as the central government has run out of money, while foreign assistance has stopped.

This is of course not the first time the Indonesian government has treated East Timorese badly. It is believed that during its 24 years of East Timor occupation, tens of thousands of innocent lives were lost, with the Indonesian military tending to turn the territory into a training ground rather that an equal part of Indonesia. When it quit East Timor in 1999, the military backed thousands of militia members who destroyed up to 80 percent of the infrastructure in the territory, prompting the United Nations to send an international combat force, rather than a peacekeeping force, to East Timor.

It is no wonder that two of Indonesia's richest provinces - Papua in the easternmost reaches and Aceh in the westernmost - observing this ongoing ill treatment of East Timorese, both during the occupation and now among the refugees, are fighting for independence. It is apparent that the Indonesian government has not learned any lessons from its experience with East Timor.

(©2002 Asia Times Online Co, Ltd. All rights reserved. Please contact content@atimes.com for information on our sales and syndication policies.)


 
Jul 13, 2002



 

Affiliates
Click here to be one)

 

 
   
         
No material from Asia Times Online may be republished in any form without written permission.
Copyright Asia Times Online, 6306 The Center, Queen’s Road, Central, Hong Kong.