Southeast Asia

Malaysia boots out illegal workers
By Anil Netto

PENANG - These are traumatic times for undocumented migrant workers and illegal immigrants in Malaysia as tough amended immigration laws came into effect on Thursday. If caught, illegal foreign workers and their employers are now staring at a mandatory six-month jail term and possibly up to six strokes of a thick rattan cane.

Not surprisingly, tens of thousands of desperate migrant workers swamped ports and exit points in an exodus of almost biblical proportions as the July 31 deadline for leaving the country approached.

Some 300,000 worried undocumented migrant workers have fled for home under an amnesty declared on March 22. Topping the list were Indonesians (244,000), Indians (19,000) and Bangladeshis (17,000). Authorities estimate that there are another 100,000-300,000 illegal migrant workers still in the country, though 50,000 more are expected to leave soon. Malaysia has some 750,000 legal foreign workers.

Taking a tough line, the immigration director general was reported in the Star national daily on Thursday as saying that the government would not extend the July 31 deadline or offer another amnesty. Those without work permits, departure tickets or special passes to prove they are returning are likely to be arrested and charged under the tough new laws. But the Jakarta Post on Thursday quoted the Indonesian manpower minister as saying he appreciated Malaysia's decision to extend the amnesty period from July 31 to August 30 for foreigners working illegally in Malaysia.

At a small terminal in Penang on Tuesday, scores of Indonesians sat outside the offices of travel agents. Many of them, clutching passports and travel documents, looked forlorn or pensive. Trying to get inside any travel agent's office proved nearly impossible. Open the door and dozens more Indonesians were crowded inside, making it impossible to step indoors.

Inside the terminal, in the waiting area, many more Indonesians were slumped on rows of seats waiting for the long ride home to Medan in Sumatra. Over in Medan and its outskirts, many of the returning migrants are now housed in numerous dormitories waiting for the provincial administration's help. Jakarta is urging its regional governors to assist stranded migrant workers by providing accommodation and financial aid to enable them to return to their home towns.

Across the South China Sea, in Sabah, thousands of undocumented migrants are catching ferries back to the southern Philippines.

Ostensibly being sent back because they are deemed to be a security threat, illegal migrant workers now realize they are no longer wanted in Malaysia, whose economy they had helped to fuel during the boom years of the early 1990s.

Many had come from Indonesia, India, Bangladesh and the Philippines in search of better life, fleeing from the cycles of poverty and violence at home. Now they are once again staring at an uncertain future.

Others such as the Muslim Rohingyas of Myanmar and Acehnese asylum seekers could face persecution if they are sent back home.

On Thursday, police arrested 135 asylum-seekers, mostly Rohingyas, Acehnese and other Indonesians, outside the United Nations refugee agency here in a bid to escape the tough new laws. They are likely to be handed over to the Immigration Department, which will decide if they will face punishments under the new law. More arrests are expected.

Activists complain the new laws do not tackle the root of the problem: human trafficking and unscrupulous agents who prey on the desperation among the poor.

For undocumented migrant workers, the so-called borderless world that globalization envisaged is a myth. Mobility of labor is only for the rich and the corporations that cross borders in a blink; at the end of the day, the poor are unwelcome outside their home countries.

While it is true that only "illegal" workers are being sent back, for years their presence in Malaysia seemed to be overlooked as they toiled at menial jobs that Malaysians shunned.

Now the construction industry, which relies heavily on migrant workers, could face work disruptions after the exodus of migrant workers.

At construction sites, many migrant workers lived in poor surroundings that Malaysians knew nothing about. Perched precariously on scaffolding with loads on their shoulders, the foreign workers took huge risks daily. As long as they were needed to build the country's magnificent monuments, it seemed they were tolerated, but only barely.

Making up 5-10 percent of the country's population, they were scapegoats, blamed for everything from higher crime rates to outbreaks of disease to Islamic militancy. And when disturbances - the causes of which remain unclear - involving migrant workers erupted, it proved to be the last straw.

Others, however, wonder if the decision to send back undocumented migrant workers has anything to do with uncertain economic prospects. The US economy has shown a surprising weakness of late, other regional economies in Asia are slowing down and Malaysia is unlikely to be spared the turbulence. Jobs could be at stake.

But if Malaysia starts whipping illegal migrant workers, it could raise unease among its neighbors. Activists in Indonesia say the arguments used to justify the deportation of Indonesian workers are unacceptable because Malaysia is actually in need of a huge number of workers to run its industries and plantations.

They point to migrant workers' allegations of extortion as one of the reasons for their frustration in Malaysia. They are also calling on the Indonesian government to ratify the international convention on the protection and rights of all migrant workers and their families to help safeguard Indonesian migrants working overseas.

(©2002 Asia Times Online Co, Ltd. All rights reserved. Please contact content@atimes.com for information on our sales and syndication policies.)


 
Aug 2, 2002



 

Affiliates
Click here to be one)

 

 
   
         
No material from Asia Times Online may be republished in any form without written permission.
Copyright Asia Times Online, 6306 The Center, Queen’s Road, Central, Hong Kong.