Southeast Asia

A moment in the sun for Cambodia's Hun Sen
By Tom Fawthrop

Cambodia’s hosting of the 8th Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) Summit earlier this month marked a personal triumph for Hun Sen, once reviled as the "illegitimate prime minister" in the Vietnamese-backed government in the 1980s. He presided with aplomb over the gathering of the major countries in the region, including China and India.

Malaysia’s Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad was among those ASEAN leaders in the 1980s who belittled Hun Sen as a mere "Vietnamese puppet" when he was appointed the world's youngest prime minister at age 33 in 1985. Little did he suspect that 17 years later he would be congratulating the same man for his role as chairman of the 10-nation summit.

Not surprisingly, Hun Sen exulted in his moment of glory, calling the staging of the summit by Cambodia as the making of history. "It was not simple history," he declared, "it was great history. Great achievements were made, and it should be a source of great pride for every Cambodian."

The son of a poor peasant family from Kompong Cham province, and a former Khmer Rouge soldier with little formal education, no one could have predicted that one day Hun Sen would rise to the top as an elected prime minister. As a 17-year-old Khmer Rouge fighting to overthrow the US-backed Lon Nol military regime, he was wounded four times, and on the last occasion shrapnel hit his eye just two days before the fall of Phnom Penh in 1975. Later on, Soviet specialists would provide him with a sophisticated glass eye, only detectable at very close range.

In spite of his handicap, it appears that he was not blinded to the evils of the Pol Pot regime. In 1977 he led a group of dissidents to seek refuge and support in neighboring Vietnam. Cambodian refugees numbered more than 100,000 in Vietnamese camps by 1978 and many of them urged Hanoi to intervene against the murderous Khmer Rouge.

After Vietnamese troops toppled Pol Pot, Hun Sen - Khmer Rouge dissident leader and refugee - was able to return to Phnom Penh. The six-member ASEAN grouping of the Cold War era demanded immediate Vietnamese withdrawal from Cambodia and refused to have any dealings with Hun Sen and the Vietnamese-installed government. The ending of the Khmer Rouge mass killings did not bring an end to Cambodia’s suffering. The shattered nation was not left in peace to rebuild and recover, but subjected to guerrilla war launched from the Thai border and backed by ASEAN with the intent of forcing a Vietnamese withdrawal.

Hun Sen’s entry into government was a baptism of fire. He had little formal education to help him cope. He was the world’s only foreign minister who had no access to the United Nations. The UN General Assembly in 1979 recorded an extraordinary vote in favor of the defunct Pol Pot government, thus depriving Cambodians of any effective representation at the UN. Those who had murdered Cambodians continued to represent them at the UN. The perversity of this diplomacy bothered neither Western countries nor ASEAN at the time.

India was the only nation outside the Soviet bloc to host the new foreign minister. The ASEAN countries put up a diplomatic wall to isolate the Phnom Penh leadership. The daunting task of rebuilding a shattered nation had to be undertaken in the face of regional hostility from Thailand, Singapore and Malaysia - the key players in ASEAN’s Cambodia strategy.

Few ASEAN leaders could ever have imagined that the prime minister they had previously shunned would one day be hosting them in Phnom Penh. Contrary to most expectations, Hun Sen has survived many changes both in Cambodia and the wider world. Soviet aid to Phnom Penh dried up and Vietnamese troops withdrew in 1989, but Hun Sen's government did not collapse.

Peace and reconciliation overtures initiated by Hun Sen eventually paved the way for the first Cambodian summit meeting with Prince Norodom Sihanouk, the president of the Coalition of Democratic Kampuchea, in Paris.

Hun Sen first met the father of the nation, who had gained independence from French colonial rulers, in 1987. The poor peasant boy, whose first education was in a Buddhist temple because his parents could not afford to pay his school fees, charmed his royal host. It was the first time in Cambodian history that a man of such humble origins had earned the right to a place at the royal table, to negotiate with a prince, and to partake of a Parisian banquet.

Since the UN peacekeeping operation which ushered in a new era after the first democratic election held in 1993, it is clear from reading Cambodia's free press that Hun Sen arouses strong passions in both his supporters and opponents.

Opposition newspapers accused Hun Sen of masterminding a coup that ousted co-prime minister Prince Norodom Ranariddh in 1997, resulting in two days of fighting in the capital between rival army factions. Cambodia's application to become a full ASEAN member was set back by the turmoil and bloodshed in Phnom Penh.

The caricature of Hun Sen as a power-hungry and corrupt dictator suspected of killing political opponents is the dominant perception in the US media and some Cambodian opposition circles.

But this one-dimensional view of the controversial leader does not entirely square with the reflective, chess-playing premier, who writes popular songs and interrupts his dinner to scribble notes about his new ideas and inspirations. Not does it do justice to his abilities as a prime minister who has long impressed diplomats. Verghese Mathews, Singapore's ambassador in Phnom Penh, regards him as "probably the most astute politician in ASEAN". "He is fast in digesting new information, he demands the facts … he is always well prepared for every meeting, whatever the subject," he says.

The self-taught leader who never finished his secondary schooling published his first book, Kampuchea: 10 Years, in 1988, and followed it up in 1991 with a thesis on economic development, Cambodia: 130 Years, which has become the basis of his ruling Cambodian People Party's free-market policies.

This endorsement of privatization and the free market has been welcomed by the World Bank and Western donor governments, but the people who have suffered most in recent years, according to non-governmental field research, are the poor farmers, the disabled, and others who have been marginalized. The prime minister who was born into their ranks seems to have forgotten their plight. These days Hun Sen revels more in playing golf with rich businesspeople and ASEAN heads of state than in listening to the bitter complaints of Cambodian farmers.

He has also failed to curb rampant destruction of Cambodia’s fast-dwindling forests, with many military officers running their own logging fiefdoms in conjunction with rapacious foreign timber companies.

On the one hand, his personel odyssey from a Khmer Rouge dissident to the young prime minister that kept the Khmer Rouge out of power in the 1980s and eventually eradicated their insurgency in the 1990s ranks him as an impressive leader of his nation. But the man who steered Cambodia into its first era of peace since the 1970 Lon Nol coup has so far not matched peace with any real measure of justice.

The ASEAN summit represents a peak of his diplomatic achievement. But unless he listens more closely to the millions of poor Cambodians, social justice is not something that Hun Sen is ever likely to deliver.

(©2002 Asia Times Online Co, Ltd. All rights reserved. Please contact content@atimes.com for information on our sales and syndication policies.)
 
Nov 20, 2002



 

Affiliates
Click here to be one)

 

 
   
         
No material from Asia Times Online may be republished in any form without written permission.
Copyright Asia Times Online, 6306 The Center, Queen’s Road, Central, Hong Kong.