Search Asia Times

Advanced Search

 
Southeast Asia

Laos: Failed resistance just a bad dream
By Richard S Ehrlich

BANGKOK - Americans supporting anti-communist Hmong guerrillas in Laos should realize they lost the US Central Intelligence Agency's support in 1975 and that the abandoned stragglers must be rescued because they cannot fight, say two European journalists who were jailed and deported after meeting the rebels.

"This community of about 600 people were mostly women and children - 60 percent of them children - and maybe 40 guys with guns - but very old guns, no ammunition - and totally unable to fight as guerrillas," said Belgian photojournalist Thierry Falise, describing a group of Hmong rebels trapped in a jungle in northern Laos.

"Their situation was very pathetic. It is definitely much more a humanitarian issue than a military issue," the Bangkok-based Falise said.

"The Hmong guerrillas are totally unable to defy the Lao government," he said.

An American Lutheran pastor, Reverend Naw Karl Mua, Falise and Bangkok-based French cameraman Vincent Reynaud were freed in Laos on Wednesday after being sentenced to 15 years in jail for meeting the rag-tag Hmong rebels. The three men insisted they were innocent after being arrested on June 4 near the rebels' camp in the Plain of Jars region of northern Laos.

They were sentenced on June 30 on flimsy charges of involvement in the death of a Lao security officer, who was killed during a jungle skirmish. Their 15-year sentences sparked an international outcry among human-rights organizations, foreign correspondents, diplomats and others demanding their freedom (see Furor over arrest of journalists, pastor in Laos, June 26).

Falise, speaking at the Foreign Correspondents Club of Thailand on Thursday alongside Reynaud, said they journeyed to Laos to report about the guerrillas but discovered that the motley band of desperate Hmong were barely able to survive hunger and disease. During the ill-fated trip, the reporters and the pastor had to eat "roots" because food was scarce, he said.

Mua, the freed Hmong-American pastor from St Paul, Minnesota, also arrived in Bangkok after being deported from Laos with the journalists but was not immediately available for comment.

The US Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) financed, trained and armed Hmong and other minority tribes in Laos during the 1960s and '70s against Lao communists and North Vietnamese. In 1975, when the United States lost its wars in Laos, Vietnam and Cambodia, thousands of Hmong crossed the Mekong River to refugee camps in Thailand. Some later found sanctuary in the US, France, Australia and elsewhere.

Today, US-based anti-communist Hmong groups demand the overthrow of the regime in Laos and claim that the guerrillas could win their fight for democracy if supporters contributed more money to their cause.

"Some Hmong-Americans, a lot of them are sincere and they still think the Hmong so-called guerrillas can take over some part of land," Falise said.

Falise, in remarks echoed by his colleague Reynaud, said that dream is a farce.

"The point now is to try to help those people - the 600 - and I understand there are five or six other groups scattered in Laos and they are in the same situation," Falise said. "They have been waiting for years and years, hidden in the jungle. A lot of them are still waiting for the Americans to come back.

"It is like a dream, even though most of them were not alive when the Americans were there almost 30 years ago. But their fathers were there, their grandfathers were there, they spoke to the Americans, and so they have been educated in that [anti-communist] talk for so many years that they also believe there are those Americans coming to save them," Falise said.

To end the misery, the US and Laotian governments should agree to allow the Hmong remnants to move to the United States so they can establish a new life, the Belgian photojournalist said.

Many Hmong in communist Laos are able to live relatively normal lives, but several thousand diehard fighters wandering the jungle are unable or unwilling to be assimilated.

If they are not rescued, they will slowly die of hunger, disease, injuries and neglect, the journalists said.

(Copyright 2003 Richard S Ehrlich.)
 
Jul 12, 2003


Laos: Lieutenant Kham's forgotten war
(Jul 9, '03)

The new battle over Laos: Trade normalization
(May 21, '03)

Laos: Bus attack highlights old divisions
(Feb 11, '03)

Affiliates
Click here to be one)

 

 
   
         
No material from Asia Times Online may be republished in any form without written permission.
Copyright 2003, Asia Times Online, 4305 Far East Finance Centre, 16 Harcourt Rd, Central, Hong Kong