DENPASAR, Bali - Experts have written the obituary of extremist violence in
Indonesia, but the violent extremists keep refusing to read the script. Friday
morning's deadly twin bombings of Western-branded hotels in Jakarta are proof
that complacency in the fight against terrorism in Indonesia remains misplaced.
Restaurant areas at the JW Marriott, site of a car bombing in 2003, and Ritz
Carlton were hit by suicide bombers at breakfast time, according to Indonesian
police, with the death toll climbing to nine in the first hours after the
attacks. Dozens were injured, and hundreds of guests evacuated.
The bombings spoil a seemingly triumphant moment for Indonesia. After veering
toward chaos a decade ago, the country
with the world's largest Muslim population had become the world's third largest
democracy. "This is a blow to us," presidential spokesperson Dino Patti Djalal
said in a broadcast interview.
Spare drill, spoil fill
The attacks also highlight shortcomings in President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono's
nuanced approach to fighting radicalism and violence.
The Friday morning explosions shattered a lull in terror attacks in Indonesia
that lasted nearly four years. They came a week after a successful, peaceful
election that appears to have given Yudhoyono, a moderate former general with a
"speak softly but carry a big stick" reputation, a second term by a landslide
margin. The attacks hit after many Western governments lifted their travel
restrictions on Indonesia, boosting the tourism trade to record levels.
Things were considered so safe that English Premier League football champions
Manchester United were due to stay at the Ritz Carlton from Saturday during a
four-day visit to Jakarta, including a scheduled match on Monday against an
Indonesian all-star team. A few hours after the bombing, Manchester United
announced it would cancel that leg of its Asian tour.
Indonesia has been the target of terrorism dating back to Christmas Eve 2000,
when churches were bombed across the archipelago. The attacks were part of
widespread Christian-Muslim clashes with shadowy military backing, aimed at
undermining reformist president Abdurrahman Wahid. He was ousted in July 2001,
but the military's Frankenstein monster took on a life of its own, gaining
strength from anti-Western sentiment in the wake of the US-led wars in
Afghanistan and then in Iraq.
In October 2002, bombs destroyed a pair of popular nightclubs in Bali,
accompanied by a calling card blast at the US Consular Agency on the popular
resort island. The Marriott attack in August 2003 killed 12. In September 2004,
a car bomb targeted the Australian Embassy in Jakarta, leaving nine dead. In
October 2005, suicide bombers hit a pair of popular restaurants in Bali.
Back to the future
The attacks on Bali and beyond were attributed to Jemaah Islamiyah (JI), a
Muslim extremist group that seeks to create a caliphate linking Muslim areas
across Southeast Asia. JI has alleged links to al-Qaeda, but operates
independently.
Experts say Friday's attacks bear the hallmarks of JI, including coordinated
attacks on multiple targets frequented by Westerners. But, after many arrests
of its top leadership, the group has reportedly splintered into factions, not
all retaining the JI name. So far no one has claimed responsibility for the
attacks.
After the second Bali bombings, the first confirmed suicide bombings in
Indonesia, Yudhoyono rallied Muslim clerics and other religious leaders to
denounce sectarian violence and extremism, declaring unequivocally that
Indonesia should not be a battleground for jihad. That high-profile
declaration, and revulsion at suicide bomber videos, helped turn the tide of
public opinion against extremist violence. The momentum held seemingly until
Friday morning.
But Yudhoyono's administration has walked a fine line in fighting homegrown
terrorism, balancing ties with the West against radical elements at home. It
has accepted support from the Australian and US governments, helping Indonesian
police crack down on terrorists. Much of the JI leadership has been arrested,
and its top bombing mastermind Azahari Husin, a Malaysian with a PhD from
Britain, was killed in a 2006 raid. "We've had a number of preventive successes
in Sumatra, in Java, and other places," presidential spokesman Djalal said. "We
always knew there are terrorist cells out there. You can never fully eradicate
them."
Yudhoyono even welcomed George W Bush for a very unpopular visit in 2006 that
avoided Jakarta and entailed a virtual lockdown (and cell phone blackout)
around the suburban presidential palace in Bogor. The inauguration of US
President Barack Obama, who spent part of his childhood living in Jakarta and
opposed the war in Iraq, promises even closer ties between the US and
Indonesian governments and has already created a great deal of grassroots
warmth toward the US.
Embracing extremists
On the other hand, Yudhoyono's political coalition includes extremist Islamic
parties that provide a home for sentiments that feed radicalism. He's largely
ignored local governments that enact radical-inspired laws, such as dress codes
and bans on females traveling alone after dark, that contradict national laws.
Yudhoyono has stoked radical fires by embracing the Palestinian cause as
Indonesia's own, in the name of Muslim solidarity. By linking his good name to
these fringe elements, Yudhoyono gives legitimacy to parties that advocate
imposing sharia law across the archipelago, whose members preach and publish
violent anti-Western Islamist screeds.
Indonesia's violence isn't all attributable to Islamic radicals. Despite
democratic trappings, there's widespread feeling of powerlessness since
government remains largely unresponsive while the elite and connected act with
impunity. Many feel Yudhoyono's regime hasn't changed things enough in that
regard. For example, it has still failed to convict the masterminds of the
murder of human rights activist Munir Said Thalib, poisoned aboard a flight on
national flag carrier Garuda in September 2004.
Yudhoyono's current cabinet includes Aburizal Bakrie as Coordinating Minister
for People's Welfare, whose family business has failed to stop the mudflow it
caused in Sidoarjo, East Java, in 2006 and adequately compensate the thousands
of displaced victims. The company was allowed to sell the affiliate to an
offshore company to avoid responsibility for the damage.
Yudhoyono's two faces embody a national personality that prefers accommodation
to confrontation. His approach had seemed to lower the political and social
temperature in Indonesia, but Friday's bombings show it's failed to extinguish
the embers of radical violence.
With his popularity proven by his win at the polls, Yudhoyono must summon the
courage to root out elements that aid and abet terrorism. It's a quality called
leadership and Indonesia needs it at this dark moment.
Longtime editor of investor rights advocate eRaider.com, Gary LaMoshihas
written for Slate and Salon.com, and works a counselor for Writing Camp
(www.writingcamp.net). He first visited Indonesia in 1994 and has tracking its
progress ever since.
(Copyright 2009 Asia Times Online (Holdings) Ltd. All rights reserved. Please
contact us about
sales, syndication and
republishing.)
Head
Office: Unit B, 16/F, Li Dong Building, No. 9 Li Yuen Street East,
Central, Hong Kong Thailand Bureau:
11/13 Petchkasem Road,
Hua Hin, Prachuab Kirikhan, Thailand 77110
