|
BOOK REVIEW
Tell-tale travelers' tales
Russia and Iran in the Great Game by Elena Andreeva
Opinion in
Russia today on Iran is divided over whether or
not to engage the country. This same division
existed in the late 19th century, the era on which
the author focuses, using the writings of Russian
travelers to Iran. What the lively book lacks is a
comparison of what European travelers to Russia
felt. - Dmitry Shlapentokh
(May 16, '08)
Tehran ponders the spoils of
victory
Hezbollah's display of strength in Lebanon leaves its backer, Iran, emboldened.
Tehran is now in a stronger position to negotiate a deal with the United States
pertaining to its nuclear file. Or it could do something radical, such as trade
off Hezbollah in exchange for a greater piece of the Iraqi cake. All options
are on the table. - Sami Moubayed (May 16, '08)
Saudis, US grapple with Iran
challenge
The reaction to the flareup in Lebanon has left Saudi Arabia (and its United
States ally) with no doubt that there are not many takers in the Arab world for
anti-Iran, anti-Hezbollah ploys. This leaves the George W Bush administration
with little choice other than to resort to back-channel diplomacy to engage
Tehran, while the Saudis, too, will have to re-asses their stance on Iran. - M K
Bhadrakumar (May 16, '08)
Bush, McCain dream on in war
land
US
President George W Bush and the man who hopes to replace him, Senator John
McCain, have divulged to the world their beautiful dreams, in which Middle East
weapons have become
ploughshares, bitter enemies lie down together as lambs and evil powers abandon
nuclear weapons. This stuff keeps the neo-cons happy, even though the politics
that will make it reality are absent. - Jim Lobe (May
16, '08)

US plan to nail Iran backfires
The George W Bush administration and the top US commander in Iraq, General
David Petraeus, plotted a sequence of events that would sensationally build
domestic US political support for a possible strike against Iran. Key to this
was to be the disclosure of a major cache of Iranian weapons found in Karbala
for use by Shi'ite militias. The weapons turned out to have nothing to do with
Iran, and worse, the Iraq government suddenly distanced itself from the US's
plan. - Gareth Porter (May 15, '08)
THE ROVING EYE
The US-Iran sound bite showdown
Iranian President Mahmud Ahmadinejad's latest comments on Israel have been
variously translated in the Western media, the most ominous saying Israel will
not save itself from "death and destruction". This will inevitably be seized on
by the George W Bush administration as more evidence that Tehran wants to
"destroy" Israel, muscling up the case for a preemptive US attack. Maybe that
is what Ahmadinejad intends. - Pepe Escobar (May
15, '08)
COMMENT
Coups and counter-coups
The Saudi Arabian accusation of an Iran-inspired "coup" by Hezbollah in Lebanon
is a misnomer. The more apt description would be a government coup, inspired by
the United States, and Hezbollah's successful "counter-coup". - Kaveh L
Afrasiabi (May 15, '08)
Bush quick onto Lebanon blame-game
President George W Bush, on tour in the Middle East, has pledged continued
United States support for the Lebanese government following its clashes with
the Shi'ite Hezbollah militia. Bush makes no secret of his belief that Iran is
behind the recent troubles. Others, though, point a finger at Washington.
(May 14, '08)
Turkey combines dialogue
with bullets
In a significant change of policy, Turkey has held high-level talks with the
Kurdistan Regional Government in Iraq in an attempt to isolate Kurdish rebels
based in northern Iraq. Both Ankara and the regional government recognize the
benefits - especially trade - of working closer together, but Turkey's military
option is still very much alive. (May 14, '08)
A deadly miscalculation in
Lebanon
As a test of strength, the Lebanese government and its Saudi Arabian backers
received a bloody nose in the confrontation with Hezbollah in Beirut. The
government woefully underestimated Hezbollah's reaction to having its
communications - spy - system interfered with. And the Iranian-backed
Hezbollah, with its convincing display of military superiority, made another
clear statement: leave our arms alone. - Sami Moubayed
(May 13, '08)
 Renewed
fighting erupts (AFP)
Hezbollah's shots ring in
Bush's ears
Just about everything the George W Bush administration has tried in the Middle
East over the past few years has undermined United States standing and
influence in the region, even as it has enhanced Tehran's. Yet as Bush visits
Saudi Arabia and Egypt this week, he might be able to turn Hezbollah's stunning
show of strength in Lebanon to his advantage. - Jim Lobe
(May 13, '08)
US misses Iran opportunity
In a busy week for Iran, key nations negotiating with it over its nuclear
program will present an incentive package for the Iranians to consider. At the
same time, International Atomic Energy Agency officials will thrash out the
last remaining issues on the Iran-IAEA plate. US President George W Bush will
also be in the region, but he won't be dropping by, even though Tehran has
indicated they might be willing to talk. - Kaveh L Afrasiabi
(May 13, '08)
Hezbollah's street fight
just a first step
Hezbollah, in taking its political grievances to the streets, was able to take
military control of Beirut in less than 48 hours, while the Lebanese army
looked on. The display of force by the opposition Shi'ite group does not leave
the government much margin for maneuvering. (May 12,
'08)
 Arab
ministers bid to end crisis (AFP)
SPENGLER
Why Israel is the world's happiest
country
At the 60th anniversary of its founding, it could be said that Israel is the
happiest nation on Earth. It is one of the wealthiest, freest and
best-educated; and it enjoys high fertility and life expectancy rates. The
light heart of the Israelis in face of continuous danger is a singularity
worthy of a closer look. (May 12, '08)
War funding and
war rhetoric
A breakdown of the US$70 billion President George W Bush requested from the US
Congress for war funding makes interesting reading, from $3 billion for
"classified activities" to $3 billion for the technology to battle explosive
devices. At the same time, the familiar Bush administration charges of Iran
sending arms into Iraq have been revived. Coincidence? - Sami Moubayed
(May 9, '08)
Iran
woos Farsi-speaking nations
Tehran has stepped up its initiative to forge closer links with the two other
Farsi-speaking nations in the region, Afghanistan and Tajikistan. Not only will
the move kick-start slow trade ties, it signals a greater degree of Iran's
integration into a region deemed important by the Shanghai Cooperation
Organization, to which Tehran is pressing its claims to join. - Kaveh L
Afrasiabi (May 9, '08)
Undiplomatically yours
Fiery and insulting language is increasingly spewing around the globe. It is
debatable whether there is a logic behind the combative and irascible words of
some world leaders, but the spoken broadsides of a Mahmud Ahmadinejad or a Kim
Jong-il are certainly less harmful than the military invasions of a George W
Bush. - Sreeram Chaulia (May 8, '08)
Pressure for Iraq to pay
its own way
The US Congress is expected to soon impose unprecedented conditions on
Iraq-related spending, including a ban on major reconstruction projects and
support for Sunni militias. The idea is that Iraq cough up more money to
rebuild itself, while at the same time challenging the wisdom of the "surge". -
Jim Lobe (May 8, '08)
SPEAKING FREELY
The Gulf's currency solution
The declining value of the US dollar,
and with it the wealth of all countries linked to it, has prompted oil states
such as Kuwait, Qatar and the United Arab Emirates to consider ending their US
dollar currency pegs. The history of the region holds the answer to their quest
for an alternative. - Nathan Lewis
(May 8, '08)
COMMENT
US terror report misses the point
The US
State Department's annual terrorism report makes
no secret that al-Qaeda is back, strong as ever.
But if al-Qaeda indeed exists on such a large and
influential scale in so many countries, is it not
time to question the logic used by the George W
Bush administration's "war on terror", which was
meant to weaken and destroy al-Qaeda in the first
place? - Ramzy
Baroud
(May 7, '08)
KEBABBLE
Tequila and Turkish nationalism
Turkey celebrates Children's Day and National Sovereignty Day on the same date,
and that's just how founding father Mustafa Kemal Ataturk wanted it. The day
celebrates youth and serves as a reminder that today's boys and girls must
protect the future of the republic. But for some parents, perhaps Armenian or
Kurdish, the jingoistic flavor of the raucous celebration can be most
disquieting. - Fazile Zahir (May 7, '08)
New offer threatens Iran's 'red
line'
The key nations negotiating over Iran's nuclear program hail their latest offer
of incentives for Tehran to give up its uranium-enrichment activities as a part
of a "twin-track strategy", the other being United Nations sanctions. There is
actually a third "war track", the drumbeat of which can be heard in Washington
and Tel Aviv. And further, the incentives directly challenge Iran's "red line".
- Kaveh Afrasiabi (May 6, '08)
Yes, the Pentagon did want to hit
Iran
Since soon after the September 11, 2001, terror attacks, it has been an open
secret that the George W Bush administration wanted to attack Iran. Now comes
further confirmation from a document quoted in then-under secretary of defense
for policy Douglas Feith's recently published account of Iraq war decisions. It
is confirmed, too, this was part of a broader plan, explicitly supported by the
US's top military leaders, to also take out Syria, Libya, Sudan and Somalia. - Gareth
Porter. (May 6, '08)
DISPATCHES FROM AMERICA
The last war and the next one
There is no end in sight to the war in Iraq, but United States Secretary of
Defense Robert Gates has been criticizing the military services for not getting
fully behind an imperial strategy for "the next war", counterinsurgency wars
across the globe similar to the (futile) one now raging in Sadr City in Bagdad.
- Tom Engelhardt (May 5, '08)
SPENGLER
The heart has its own unreason
In one of the weirder acts of recent diplomacy, a delegation of robed and
turbaned Iranian mullahs went to Rome to declare with due solemnity they shared
the pope's view that reason and faith are compatible. The eventual outcome of
the meeting will not be decided by the Iranian clergy or the Holy See, but by
people such as journalist Magdi Allam, who converted from Islam to Catholicism.
- Spengler (May 5, '08)
Energized Iran builds more bridges
In terms of whom it conducts its energy business with, Iran keeps all its
options open, and it will not allow itself to be pushed out of the European
market as exports are the bridge that will facilitate its all-round integration
with the Western world. Tehran's hectic diplomatic activity in this regard has
put the "Iran Six" countries dealing with its nuclear dossier on the defensive:
none of them wants confrontation with Iran. - M K Bhadrakumar
(May 5, '08)
How under-the-gun Iran plays it
cool
What Iranian leaders dream of is an Iran respected as a major power. To this
end, they have little choice, faced with the enmity of the globe's "sole
superpower" - its sanctions and its ring of military bases - but to employ a
sophisticated counter-encirclement foreign policy. And given President Mahmud
Ahmadinejad's place in the country's politico-religious politics, he might be
betting on the usefulness of an American air assault. - Pepe Escobar
(May 2, '08)
Iran moving into the big
league
From the Persian Gulf to the Caspian region, the Caucasus, Central Asia, South
Asia and beyond, Iran thanks to its geographical location is an ideal
connecting bridge that has not until now fully exploited its advantageous
"equidistance" from India and Europe. This is exemplified in the US$7.6 billion
gas pipeline that will flow from Iran to Pakistan to India, and which is
finally close to reality. Tehran is ambitiously moving from regional power to
global power. - Kaveh L Afrasiabi (May 2, '08)
BOOK REVIEW
America's university of
imperialism
Soldiers of Reason by Alex Abella
The RAND Corporation was the Cold War granddaddy think-tank of them all, one of
the most unusual private organizations in the field of international relations,
and it's still with us. It helped administrations plan and fight the Vietnam
War, turning theory into an all-too-grim reality. Yet its record of advice on
cardinal policies involving war and peace, arms races and decisions to resort
to armed force has been abysmal. -Chalmers Johnson
(May 2, '08)
The heat is on Muqtada
The fierce battle raging in Baghdad's Sadr City between Muqtada al-Sadr's Mahdi
Army and United States and Iraqi forces has claimed more than 1,000 lives over
the past few weeks. What is not clear is the motive behind the offensive
against the Shi'ite militia. It could be the Americans, trying to nip in the
bud any united front between Muqtada and Sunnis. Or the Iranians, wanting to
eliminate a potential thorn in their side. Either way, Muqtada has a fight on
his hands. - Sami Moubayed (May 1, '08)

Sadr City fight fuels Iraq bloodshed (AFP)
Al-Qaeda
searches for unity in Iraq
A series of messages from al-Qaeda deputy Ayman al-Zawahiri and its chief in
Iraq, Abu Hamza al-Mujahir, indicates al-Qaeda is pulling out all the stops to
try to prevent the Sunni Iraqi mujahideen from militarily winning the war but
then losing the political spoils because of disunity. - Michael Scheuer
(May 1, '08)
Iran-US talks await new
leadership era
It is unlikely either the George W Bush administration or hardliners in Tehran
will initiate serious bilateral talks prior to the US presidential elections in
November. The prospect of dialogue with Iran seems plausible after the vote,
but only if the next US president is willing to risk strengthening President
Mahmud Ahmadinejad's hand before Iran's 2009 presidential polls.
(Apr 30, '08)
India
raises a toast to Iran
In a clear reference to the United States, Delhi has asserted that India and
Iran "are perfectly capable of managing all aspects of their relationship", and
is solidifying a number of agreements previously stalled with Tehran, mostly
related to energy. The economic imperatives are obvious, but there are also
compelling political reasons. - Siddharth
Srivastava (May 1, '08)
Iran
holds key to India's energy insecurity
In terms of its energy needs, India has woken to the simple fact that nearly
all roads lead to Tehran, both as a source of energy as well as an outlet for
other countries' energy exports to India. This could be the first step in a
whole gamut of economic, trade, cultural, political and even security
cooperation. - Kaveh L Afrasiabi (Apr 29,
'08)
US embroiled in de-basing
deal
The George W Bush administration is in crucial negotiations with the government
of Prime Minister Nuri al-Maliki over the future relationship between Iraq and
the United States. The core issue relates to permanent military bases, but no
one is saying so, even as a year-end deadline looms. - Daniel Smith
(Apr 29, '08)
DISPATCHES FROM AMERICA
Selling the
president's general
Just as President George W Bush's favorite general, David Petraeus, was given
another promotion by being nominated as head of US Central Command, revelations
broke of the Pentagon's extensive propaganda operation to embed retired
military officers in the mainstream US media. The two events - and the "surge"
in Iraq - are inextricably linked. - Tom Engelhardt (Apr
28, '08)
Iran steps into enemy's territory
Iranian President Mahmud Ahmadinejad's swing though Sri Lanka, Pakistan and
India this week takes him to capitals firmly in the United States camp. Tehran
needs a counter to the regime of sanctions and limitations imposed by the West.
The South Asian countries need Iran's business, so much so they will risk
backlashes in defying Washington's will on isolating Iran. - Kaveh L Afrasiabi
(Apr 28, '08)
Syria bristles at
US charges
Washington's accusations that Syria and North Korea cooperated on a nuclear
site that was allegedly destroyed by an Israeli air strike last September, are
being laughed off in Damascus as another "convenient inaccuracy". The charge
would be downright funny, if it didn't come with the dangerous potential of
mushrooming into what happened when Iraq was accused of developing weapons of
mass destruction. - Sami Moubayed (Apr 28, '08)
THE
ROVING EYE
Hillary, the war chick
It was a silly question to begin with, but Democratic hopeful Hillary Clinton
jumped in boots and all, saying if she were US president and Iran attacked
Israel with nuclear weapons, she would "obliterate" Iran. Clinton's positioning
spells Imperial Washington in all its glory - and hubris. - Pepe Escobar
(Apr 25, '08)
Recruiting the bottom of
the barrel
According to the US Congress, the number of recruits requiring a waiver to join
the US Army because of a criminal record has more than doubled since 2004, to
one of every eight new soldiers. Ominously, a link between pre-service behavior
and criminal acts while in the military has been confirmed in studies. - David
Isenberg(Apr 25, '08)
Petraeus' rise lets Cheney
loose on Iran
General David Petraeus' nomination as the new head of the US Central Command,
in place of the "unpliable" Admiral William Fallon, adds a strident voice in
support of the George W Bush administration's policies toward Iran and Iraq. It
also gives Vice President Dick Cheney greater freedom of action to exploit the
option of an air attack against Iran during the administration's final months.- Gareth
Porter (Apr 24, '08)

US to detail N Korea-Syria nuclear
cooperation (AFP)
New momentum for US-Iran dialogue
This week's summit in Kuwait of Iraq and its neighbors, although not officially
breaking any ice between Iran and the United States, points to the two
countries showing a new willingness to demonstrate their support for the
embattled Baghdad government, as well as the latter's attempts to build bridges
with its Arab neighbors. - Kaveh L Afrasiabi
(Apr 24, '08)
US paradox
of construction and destruction
In the 1960s a construction consortium, The Vietnam
Builders, completed a nearly miraculous construction effort in South Vietnam
and gave a strong fiscal stimulus to the US economy. But Vietnam showed that
war is not the same as nation building; greater militarization only brings more
suffering and accentuates the paradox of simultaneous construction and
destruction, which unfortunately has found painful new life in Iraq. -
James M Carter
(Apr 24, '08)
Israel changes tune on Iran
Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert has been unequivocal recently in his
assurances that Iran will not get the bomb. This is a sea-change for the
Israeli leader, who until now has been careful to keep "all options" on the
table, and reflects the conviction that diplomatic means will be central in
stopping Tehran from going nuclear. (Apr 23, '08)
Muqtada's biggest battle already
won
Popularity is the treasury of a guerrilla movement that sustains it in
asymmetrical war against conventionally superior foes. That's why Muqtada
al-Sadr's Mahdi Army, now acknowledged as the largest social welfare dispenser
in Iraq, is such a formidable force: with the people behind it, it simply
cannot be defeated, as the US is finding out. - Sreeram Chaulia
(Apr 22, '08)
Iran's 'bomb' and dud intelligence
Just as the intelligence community in the United States and Britain took a
beating over the misreading of the flow of information about Iraqi weapons of
mass destruction before the invasion of 2003, assessments on Iran's nuclear
program - which vary wildly - have aroused incredulity. At stake is a far more
dangerous war with Iran than the one with Iraq, and one that continued
intelligence failures could precipitate. - Richard M Bennett
(Apr 22, '08)
Carter spreads a new doctrine
Former US president Jimmy Carter was well received this week in Syria, where he
met a range of people, including the head of the political bureau of Hamas, a
US-listed terrorist organization. Despite Carter's stated aims, there will be
no immediate breakthroughs in the Middle East, but he does have the ear of
think-tanks and decision-makers in Washington. - Sami Moubayed
(Apr 22, '08)
KEBABBLE
Turkey makes
peace with Pippa
The rape and murder of 33-year-old Italian peace activist Pippa Bacca has
shocked and saddened Turkey. The tragedy of the bride-to-be dying for the cause
of peace has set the nation's imagination aflame. In a country of hopeless
romantics, idealists and dreamers, Pippa Bacca may well have, in death, found
her true spiritual home. - Fazile Zahir
(Apr 22, '08)
Room for two: US, Iran in the
Middle East While keeping Iran out of
events in the Middle East isn't a realistic
option, bringing Tehran in from the cold will have
huge repercussions for the region's order and for
the US and its allies. The question is no longer
what economic incentives are required to change
Tehran's behavior. Instead, it's what role to give
it in stabilizing Iraq and in the region as a
whole. - Trita Parsi (Apr 21,
'08)
Petraeus hid Maliki's
resistance to US troops US General David Petraeus's
portrayal of last month's offensive in Basra by
Iraqi forces as inept masked a quite different
picture in which Iraqi Prime Minister Nuri
al-Maliki launched the attack to forestall a much
bigger US-led operation against the Mahdi Army.
Maliki did not want the US push to succeed. - Gareth Porter (Apr 18,
'08)
A birthday present for
Mubarak Eighty-year-old President
Hosni Mubarak faces trouble as never before in his
26 years at Egypt's helm. For myriad reasons,
people are angry, which alarms "Big sister
Egypt's" neighbors, and particularly Cairo's ally,
the United States. The beleaguered president could
well recall the events leading to the demise of
the last king of Egypt in 1952. - Sami Moubayed (Apr 18,
'08)
A diplomatic shuffle on
Iran The
meeting of heavyweight nations in China over
Iran's nuclear program, while not surprisingly
failing to produce any startling breakthrough, has
set the stage for a mini-breakthrough on the
chessboard of this international crisis. This game
is inextricably linked to a bigger chessboard, the
one involving Iraq, over which the United States
and Iran - despite their rhetoric - share the
common interest of the country's stabilization. -
Kaveh L Afrasiabi
(Apr 17, '08)
Basra: Echoes of
Vietnam As it
did in Vietnam, the United States looks at Iraq
though the lens of firepower and troop
deployments. But war is not just about things that
blow up, and occupiers always ignore the point of
view of the occupied. Similarly, for a parallel to
the 1968 Tet offensive in Vietnam, Iraq now has
its battle for Basra. - Conn Hallinan (Apr 17,
'08)
THE
ROVING EYE My militia is more
untouchable than yours Iraq, transfixed by no less
than 28 militias, is burning - again. Prime
Minister Nuri al-Maliki has made a lot of noise
about an ongoing government crackdown on these
groups. But some militias are more untouchable
than others: the Kurdish Peshmergas fall under the
radar, while Muqtada al-Sadr's are bang in the
line of fire. - Pepe
Escobar (Apr 17, '08)
Turkey wrestles with a
'judicial coup' Turkey's Constitutional Court
is considering whether to ban the highly popular
ruling Justice and Development Party on the
grounds it has become a cove for anti-secular
activity. At stake are profound domestic political
changes, and Ankara's controversial bid for
European Union membership. (Apr 17,
'08)
Iran homes in on the
Caspian With United States and
United Nations sanctions escalating the pressures
on Iran, particularly in the Middle East and
Persian Gulf, Tehran is seeking an outlet for
trade and investment in the Caspian region, luring
potential partners with lucrative
production-sharing agreements. If only the
littoral states could agree among themselves. - Kaveh L Afrasiabi (Apr 16,
'08)
US juggles double-edged Iran
sanctions Ahead of a meeting this week
in China of all of the major powers dealing with
Iran's nuclear program, the United States
continues its push for unilateral sanctions
against Tehran. Yet a bill making its way through
the senate may potentially further undermine the
international support Washington seeks to confront
Iran and "change its behavior". (Apr 15,
'08)
Fallujah fights a
never-ending battle Three years after the
devastating United States-led siege of the city,
residents of Fallujah continue to struggle with a
shattered economy, infrastructure and a crippling
lack of medical care and drinking water. Liberated
Fallujah, many residents say, is now just a big
jail. - Ali
al-Fadhily and Dahr Jamail (Apr 15,
'08)
SPENGLER Ehud Olmert on the Damascus
road Guerilla movements require
arms, money and intelligence from sympathetic
states. Hamas and Hezbollah would represent no
threat to Israel without the backing of Syria and
Iran. Military and political logic requires Israel
to attack their sponsors, rather than their
militants embedded among civilians. Iran is hard
to reach, but Syria is a sitting duck. (Apr 14,
'08)
DISPATCHES FROM
AMERICA Oops, our bad
United States air power
has, in the past six-and-a-half years, been an
effective force in the "war for terror", not
against it. From the point of view of one's actual
enemies, they can't be bombed and strafed often
enough, because when they are, it is more or less
guaranteed to create their newest recruits. - Tom Engelhardt (Apr 14,
'08)
US edges closer to engaging
Iran Iran
has condemned attacks on the Green Zone in
Baghdad, distancing itself from provocative acts
against the United States, while also downplaying
Israel's massive military exercises. This comes as
Tehran acknowledges the receipt of an official
Washington suggestion for a next round of talks on
Iraq. With the US position eroding fast in Iraq,
there is a strong sense the George W Bush
administration is taking the plunge for
unconditional talks with Iran. - M K Bhadrakumar (Apr 11,
'08)
Tehran keeps its options
open Iran's
reluctance to jump into another round of dialogue
with the United States over Iraq stems from its
belief that no tangible results can be gained as
long as Washington constantly demonizes Iran and
fails to appreciate its true role in Iraq. - Kaveh L Afrasiabi (Apr 11,
'08)
TARGET IRAN,
Part 2 Euro mantra undermines
sanctions Chinese exporters have a
three-line code to beat United States-imposed
sanctions on Iran. The mantra's heart - the euro
and the Europe-focused SWIFT banking transaction
network - point to the likely long-term winners
and losers in this financial tug-of-war. (Apr 11,
'08) This concludes a two-part
article.
Mixed Muslim message in 'war
on terror' The majority of
the 57 member states of the Organization of the
Islamic Conference lend territorial or military
assistance of different shades to the United
States' "war on terror". This appears to belie any
imminent "clash of civilizations". Yet while the
governments side with the US, their citizens have
vehemently anti-American positions. - Sreeram Chaulia (Apr 11,
'08)
A US war at the
polls While
the George W Bush administration claims its Iraq
policy is not beholden to public opinion polls in
the United States, it is increasingly difficult to
view the respective aspects of US strategy, as
unveiled in congressional hearings this week, as
doing anything more than reducing violence now to
quell domestic dissent against the war. (Apr 11,
'08)
THE ROVING
EYE Evil Iran, the new
al-Qaeda The
recent opinion piece by senators Joe Lieberman and
Lindsey Graham was soothing for George W Bush
administration supporters in its assurances that
the "surge" in Iraq is successful as well as
noble. It also served as a convenient demonizing
of Iran. As for the majority of the American
public, which has had enough of an endless war,
it's nothing but an insult to their collective
intelligence. - Pepe Escobar (Apr 9,
'08)
War and peace, Israeli
style Israel's massive military
exercises on the Syrian border have significantly
raised tension between the two countries, even as
their leaders downplay the development. At first
glance, it is in nobody's interest to see yet
another war. Yet in their relentless pursuit of
Hezbollah, the Israelis have good reason to wage a
limited battle on the group's natural ally - Syria
- and then seek peace on their own terms. -
Sami Moubayed (Apr 9,
'08)
Muqtada rides the
tiger General
David Petraeus and US envoy Ryan Crocker are not
alone as they go through their paces before the US
Congress. There's a ghostly figure beside them,
that of "hot-headed", "radical cleric" Muqtada
al-Sadr, who has made a mockery of their plans for
a pacified Iraq. British author and journalist Patrick Cockburn in a
book out this week sheds new light on Muqtada, the
canny, cautious, strategically savvy political
leader who has called for a million-strong march
in Baghdad this week. (Apr 9, '08)
Iraqi rogues and a false
proxy war The
strong resistance put up against United States and
Iraqi forces in Basra was by rogue militiamen who
have split from Muqtada al-Sadr's Mahdi Army and
come under Iranian control. That, anyway, is the
line General David Petraeus is expected to follow
in his congressional testimony. Yet there is no
evidence such Iranian-backed special groups exist,
and Tehran's real strategy in Iraq bears no
resemblance to the one portrayed in the US proxy
war narrative. - Gareth Porter
(Apr 8, '08)
CAMPAIGN
OUTSIDER Questioning to win in
Iraq The US
presidential candidates hope to get useful answers
when the top US military commander and diplomat
testify on Capitol Hill. But the key to the
election may be asking the right question. -
Muhammad
Cohen (Apr 8, '08)
KEBABBLE Gory matricide fixates a
nation When
troubled Turkish 21-year-old Basak Aydintug
murdered her domineering mother she broke one of
the world's most entrenched taboos and the
shocking crime has fascinated the press. The
mother has received
post-mortem acclaim for
her brilliance as a person and a doctor; and
Basak will probably have a film made about her.
But a subsequent matricide has failed to engaged
the public, drawing questions about the Turkish
media's preference for photogenic murderesses.
(Apr 8, '08)
The general and the
trap The
George W Bush administration's missteps in Iraq
will not be apparent in the shadowboxing among
Washington's "best and brightest" when General
David Petraeus, American "surge" commander in
Iraq, and US ambassador Ryan Crocker testify
before congressional committees on Tuesday. And
any debate focused on military success or failure
is a trap, with Petraeus' testimony as the bait
for unwary Democratic presidential hopefuls. - Ira Chernus (Apr 7,
'08)
Yes, it's that 'q' word
again The
United States risks getting bogged down in Iraq
for a long time to come, the influential experts
who advised the bipartisan Iraq Study Group
conclude in a new report. They suggest two
possible alternatives to the current policy of an
"unconditional" US commitment to Iraq, and their
views will almost certainly give dissenters
ammunition in Tuesday's critical congressional
testimony. - Jim Lobe
(Apr 7, '08)
Presidential paths diverge
over terror focus The recent Shi'ite clashes in
Iraq have forced that country, along with
Afghanistan, back onto the agendas of the US
presidential hopefuls. Democrats Hillary Clinton
and Barack Obama and Republican John McCain say
they will bolster efforts in Afghanistan. The
unanswered question is whether the more important
battle with Islamic extremism is in Iraq or
Afghanistan, and how the two theaters affect one
another. (Apr 4, '08)
Muqtada out of step in
Shi'ite dance The attempted crackdown by
the Nuri al-Maliki government on Muqtada al-Sadr's
Mahdi Army vividly illustrates how politics in
Iraq have slipped into a Shi'ite vs Shi'ite
battle. The Muslim group can no longer be viewed
as one big family - thanks to the preferences of
Iran, and the ambitious Muqtada. - Sami Moubayed (Apr 4,
'08)
BOOK
REVIEW A neo-con in the
works Surrender Is Not an
Option by John Bolton The Yale-educated son of
a Boston firefighter, Bolton makes no secret of
his contempt for liberal thinking and his urge for
confrontation. The controversial former US
ambassador to the United Nations explains his
decision to go it alone at the UN with a mission
to "improve America's position" rather than to
improve the organization. Bolton eventually failed
on both counts because his hardline approach kept
him from realizing that the two are inextricably
linked. - Alexander
Casella (Apr 4, '08)
THE ROVING
EYE The other Iraqi civil
war Even
under George W Bush logic, "the terrorists" won
and Iran won, this time in the battle of Basra. In
the north of Iraq, though, the pieces are falling
into place for an alliance between the United
States, Israel and a "greater Kurdistan". If only
the pesky Iraqi nationalist Sunnis and Shi'ites
don't get in the way. - Pepe Escobar (Apr 2,
'08)
Iran torpedoes US plans for
Iraqi oil With the Iranian
Revolutionary Guards Corps showing how much
control it has over the killing fields of Iraq, by
stopping the fighting in the southern city of
Basra, Iran has made both the Iraqi and United
States governments look very foolish. Far beyond
that, Iran has frustrated the joint US-British
objective of gaining control of Basra, without
which their strategy for establishing control over
the fabulous oil fields of southern Iraq will not
work. - M K Bhadrakumar
(Apr 2, '08)
Muqtada's fight puts US to
flight In the
United States' estimation, Muqtada al-Sadr and his
Mahdi Army were ripe for the picking after months
of being harassed by "cordon and search"
operations across Iraq. The heavy offensive in
Basra was to further - if not fatally - weaken the
Shi'ite militia. That Muqtada's men were more than
ready for a fight has the George W Bush
administration scrambling to distance itself from
the gross miscalculation. - Gareth Porter (Apr 1,
'08)
Iran sees hope in war of
words High-level and at times
contradictory comments by United States officials
on Iran's nuclear program heat the pot of
allegations against the country without bringing
it to boiling point. From Tehran's perspective, in
this war of attrition being fought in the arena of
world public opinion, the chips are piling up
against the US and its allies. - Kaveh L Afrasiabi (Apr 1,
'08)
Shi'ite fight shows other
side of the COIN The struggle between Iraqi
forces and Muqtada al-Sadr's Mahdi Army calls into
question the US's new counterinsurgency doctrine
(COIN) and bodes ill for the country's
stabilization. Prime Minister Nuri al-Maliki has
made a big gamble - if the fighting causes more
misery in southern Iraq, his government will be
doomed by its chief constituency. - Ehsan M Ahrari (Mar 31,
'08)
The day the US declared war
on Iran North
Korea was a test-run for the United States' new
strategy of "shock and awe" financial sanctions
against Iran. On March 20, Washington declared two
acts of war: one against Iran's banks and one
against any financial institution anywhere in the
world that tries to do business with an Iranian
bank. The next step is to designate Iran's central
bank as a financial criminal; the impact of this
will be the financial equivalent to the first
bombs falling on Baghdad in 2003. - John McGlynn (Mar 31,
'08)
Jitters over Syria's Kurdish
clashes The
death of three Kurds in clashes with security
forces in the Kurdish district of Qamishly in
northeastern Syria has angered Kurds not only in
Syria but also in neighboring Iraq and Turkey.
This is very bad timing for a region on the verge
of explosion. - Sami
Moubayed (Mar 28, '08)
SPEAKING
FREELY September 11 was a third-rate
operation From the day of the attack,
evidence has accumulated that September 11, 2001,
was never more than a third-rate operation. This
has been evident from both what the plot did, and
what it didn't attempt, or do. The American public
shares the blame for the plot's success, causes
and ensuing ramifications; through its collective
narcissism, dereliction of responsibility - and
fear. - Bohdan Pilacinski
(Mar 27, '08)
Bush and Bin Laden's virtual
war The
George W Bush administration's "war on terror"
could be summed up in three words -
"fragmentation, diminution, destruction". That's
fragmentation brought about by "creative
destabilization", as in Iraq, Lebanon and
Palestine; diminution of American prestige, both
military and political, and thus of American
power; destruction of political consensus within
the US for a strong global role. And all this to
the advantage of Osama bin Laden. - Mark Danner (Mar 27,
'08)
Muqtada cuts
free Fighting in the south of Iraq
between Muqtada al-Sadr's Madhi Army and a rival
Shi'ite organization fitted in uniforms of the
Iraqi security forces mark the end of Muqtada's
self-imposed ceasefire. It also signals a major
defeat for the US military command's strategy
aimed at weakening the Mahdi Army. - Gareth Porter (Mar 27,
'08)
A sheikha, a queen and a
first lady The dazzling arrivals of
three young first ladies to power in Doha, Amman
and Damascus have unveiled a new and important
realm of possibilities for the wives of Arab
leaders. The "Big Three" have enchanted much of
the world with their grace and elegance, and have
taken increasingly active roles as businesswomen,
entrepreneurs and nation-builders. - Sami Moubayed (Mar 27,
'08)
US moves towards engaging
Iran Sunday's mortar
attacks on the Green Zone in Baghdad may be a
harbinger of things to come unless the United
States accommodates Iranian interests. And with
the George W Bush administration's grudging
admission of the realities of the political
alignment in Tehran, "unconditional talks" between
the countries are in the offing. The real issue
now is whether the emboldened leadership in Tehran
shares Washington's sense of urgency. - M K Bhadrakumar (Mar 26,
'08)
Very sick, and not getting
better Thousands of doctors have
fled Iraq or been killed in the five years since
the US invasion. There is a woeful shortage of
hospital beds and equipment, and even when
patients can dodge the bullets and militias to get
to a hospital, most can't afford to pay. The
humanitarian situation is one of the world's most
critical, a report by the International Committee
of the Red Cross concludes. - Alexander Casella (Mar 26,
'08)
The fateful Battle of
Baghdad In
its five years under American occupation, Baghdad
has been transformed from a metropolis into an
urban desert, and various American "surges" have
proven, in the end, disastrous. For the residents
of the battered city, it's an endless wait for the
Americans to leave. - Michael Schwartz (Mar 26,
'08)
KEBABBLE Turkey seeks a more modern
Islam Turkish
highest religious authority has instructed top
theologians to re-evaluate the oral traditions
relating to the Prophet Mohammad. It's an
ambitious attempt at a fundamental revision of the
holy texts and Turkey has the capacity to do
nothing less than recreate Islam, changing it from
a religion whose rules must be obeyed, to one
designed to serve the needs of people in a modern
secular democracy. - Fazile Zahir (Mar 26,
'08)
DISPATCHES FROM
AMERICA Bonfire of puppy-tossers, and
the beer test A widely viewed Internet
video of a US Marine throwing a cute puppy to its
death in a ditch in Iraq has Americans gnashing
their teeth at the appalling actions of a native
son. It's disturbing stuff, but where's America's
all-consuming concern for the hundreds of
thousands of dead Iraqi humans? It's this
dichotomy that exposes the real reasons for the
war, and the real risks that those who advocate
its quick conclusion are taking. - Julian Delasantellis (Mar 25,
'08)
THE ROVING
EYE Shocked, awed and left to
rot US Vice President Dick Cheney
is spot on when he talks of "phenomenal changes"
in Iraq. Millions of Iraqis have lost their homes,
their jobs, their families, their dreams and in
countless cases their own lives because of a
pre-emptive war. And anti-American Muqtada
al-Sadr will ultimately be the lord of what
remains of Iraq. - Pepe
Escobar (Mar 19, '08)
DISPATCHES FROM
AMERICA Already counting to
six When it comes to the American
position in Iraq, short of an act of God, the
sixth anniversary of George W Bush's war of choice
is going to dawn much like the fifth one, no
matter who's elected US president in November. -
Tom
Engelhardt (Mar 19, '08)
Khomeini's grandchild breaks
her silence The outspoken views of Zahra
Eshraghi, granddaughter of Ruhollah Khomeini, the
founder of the Islamic revolution in Iran, have
put her at odds with Tehran's conservative
hardliners and have drawn a gag order from her own
prestigious family. But the recent mass
disqualification of reformists in the March 14
parliamentary elections and what she feels are
"delusions" maintained by the current regime have
moved her to break her silence. (Mar 18,
'08)
IRAN
VOTES A new political space
opens As
widely expected, "principalists" - conservatives -
have taken the majority of seats in the
parliamentary elections, although reformists have
fared better than anticipated. With some seats
going to a second round of polling over the next
few weeks, the United States' anti-Iran rhetoric
will further strengthen the hands of the
conservatives. - Kaveh L
Afrasiabi (Mar 17, '08)
Battle of the
conservatives In Iran there are reformers,
conservatives and the really conservative. Those
running for office in Friday's parliamentary
elections come from the last category. Reformers
are expected to win no more than 30 of the 290
seats up for grabs. - Sami
Moubayed (Mar 14, '08)
Israel raises the ante
against Iran Israeli Foreign Minister
Tzipi Livni's "charm" offensive against Iran in
the United States is ominously reminiscent of the
sabre-rattling before the invasion of Iraq. This
time, however, the stakes are higher as the way is
being opened for another disastrous war in the
Middle East, since Israel is incapable of peace
with the Palestinians. - Kaveh L Afrasiabi (Mar 13,
'08)
Turkey and Iraq take a step
at a time The Turkish incursion into
northern Iraq against Kurdish rebels achieved what
it was meant to, in that Ankara demonstrated its
willingness to undertake such a bold move. The
next step will be more difficult: joint
national-regional delegations on both the Iraqi
and the Turkish sides to take small steps for
cross-border cooperation. - Robert M Cutler (Mar 13,
'08)
COMMENT American Icarus flirted with
fire The
widespread view is that US CENTCOM commander
Admiral William "Fox" Fallon was sacrificed by the
George W Bush administration because he disagreed
with its policies on Iran while also saving the US
from marauding Chinese. This is bunk. Fallon fell
because he committed a far worse crime for a
military veteran - he talked out of turn. -
Mark Perry (Mar 12,
'08)
Fallon falls: Iran should
worry
Admiral
William Fallon's resignation as the United States'
top commander in the Middle East removes one of
the most outspoken opponents of the George W Bush
administration's hard line on Iran. Defense
Secretary Robert Gates immediately dismissed as
"ridiculous" suggestions that Fallon's departure
signaled that the US planned to go to war with
Iran, but certainly now "all options" are back on
the table. - Gareth
Porter (Mar 12, '08)
KEBABBLE Just what's bugging the
Turks? After
20 years of research, Turkish techies can now
encrypt mobile phones past the point of outside
surveillance. This, they say, will put Turkey at
the forefront of protecting information and
privacy. But the era of Ankara's "big ears", with
its widespread wire-tapping trickery and
subsequent scandals, is not necessarily over. - Fazile Zahir (Mar 12,
'08)
COMMENT Big bang or chaos: What's
Israel up to? Whether Israel's military
logic revolved around the "chaos theory" or the
"big bang", its iron-fist intervention in Gaza was
neither to send a message to the Israeli public
nor to "commit genocide". Rather, Israel's plans
are regional, with Gaza being a testing ground. -
Ramzy Baroud (Mar 11,
'08)
A way to stave off Iran
sanctions Indonesia, by abstaining from
the United Nations Security Council vote to impose
a third round of sanctions on Iran over its
nuclear program, showed up many of its fellow
travelers in the Non-Aligned Movement. With their
two-thirds majority at the UN, NAM states, given
the political will, have the power to influence
this major international crisis by pre-empting
further UN action against Tehran. - Kaveh L Afrasiabi (Mar 11,
'08)
SPENGLER
Should Islam be blamed for
'barbaric' acts? The issue of Muslim
"barbarism", including honor killings, genital
mutilation and other forms of violence against
women, has risen in prominence in Europe 's
political agenda. The question appears to be: Do
Muslims commit barbaric acts because they are bad
Muslims or because they are good Muslims? (Mar 10,
'08)
Iran shifts focus fully on
Iraq Whether
it's a part of a secret deal with the United
States or not, Iran does appear to be distancing
itself from its proxies in the Arab world, at the
same time showing a free hand in Iraq. The days of
Hezbollah in Lebanon could be numbered. - Sami Moubayed (Mar 10,
'08)
An admiral takes on the White
House Admiral
William Fallon, the US's top commander in the
Middle East, has frequently angered the George W
Bush administration by saying that the military
option against Iran is "off the table". Fallon
believes this is necessary to calm the very
regimes, such as Egypt, the administration hopes
to enlist to support its anti-Iran line. - Gareth Porter (Mar 10,
'08)
In Iran, fashion as
protest
Iran's
young, urban and increasingly hip "fashionistas"
have little time for the state-imposed dress code
or its enforcers, the so-called morality police.
They'd rather be shopping or grooming at one of
Tehran's ultra-trendy boutiques catering to the
image obsessed. The more authorities try to
enforce the code, the more it seems Iranians want
to push the boundaries of personal fashion. (Mar 10,
'08)
War is hell - and hellishly
expensive The estimated cost of one
week of the United States' global wars is US$3.5
billion. But exactly where is that money going?
When Congress passed the latest Pentagon
war-fighting supplemental request, it was said to
be "for the troops", but a surprisingly small
amount actually goes to them. Newfangled weapons,
private security contractors and big business eat
up a large portion, yet hundreds of millions of
dollars are unaccounted for. - William D Hartung (Mar 7,
'08)
THE ROVING
EYE As alliances shift, Iran
wins. Again The George W Bush
administration promoted a Turkey-Israel axis, a
Sunni Arab "axis of fear" and then a Saudi-Israeli
nexus, always trying to isolate Iran. None of
these concoctions has worked, and there are even
hints that Washington and Tehran have concluded a
secret deal brokered by Saudi Arabia to hammer out
contentious issues. This might be fanciful, but
the bottom line is that Iran sees itself as the
ultimate victor of the US war on Iraq. - Pepe Escobar (Mar 6,
'08)
Iran-Iraq ties show US the
way Tehran's
enormous influence in Iraq is there to stay, given
Iran's proximity and religious and historical
connections, highlighted by President Mahmud
Ahmadinejad's recent visit. This leaves the US
with little choice but to adjust its anti-Iran
policy to accommodate Iran's regional clout. - Kaveh L Afrasiabi (Mar 6,
'08)
Iran gas: China waits as
India wavers The possibility of India
buying Iranian gas by way of a pipeline running
through mutual neighbor Pakistan has been a
talking point for the past decade. Yet as
Islamabad and Tehran prepare to sign a gas
purchase agreement this month, India is holding
back amid security concerns and US disapproval of
the plan. Energy-hungry China may seize the
opportunity. - Siddharth
Srivastava (Mar 5, '08)
Europe alert to triple terror
threat Al-Qaeda has never made a
secret of its eagerness to target Europe, but the
continent faces a triple threat: al-Qaeda of the
Islamic Maghreb, al-Qaeda Pakistan and the rogue,
al-Qaeda-affiliated "lone jihadis" whom the French
|