Street dwellers visible but ignored
By Bharat Dogra
NEW DELHI - Kalimuddin makes a living selling ice water from an insulated
cart outside Delhi's bustling railway station. He is as homeless now as
the day he arrived here from his village in eastern Bihar state 20 years
ago.
At night, Kalimuddin sleeps where he can on the pavements. He cannot use
the government-run shelters because he has to keep an eye on the cart,
hired out from a demanding owner.
Jaswinder, a rickshaw puller at the nearby Ajmeri gate area is better off.
At night, he can turn his rickshaw upside down for a temporary home and
sleep under it. He even has a plastic sheet to spread over it for rainy
nights. Winters are tougher for then Jaswinder must hire out a quilt at
around 25 cents a night to keep from freezing. ''That's too much but if I
buy my own quilt I have nowhere to keep such a bulky thing.''
There are no reliable estimates on the total number of homeless people who
live where they can on the streets of India's large metropolises of Delhi,
Mumbai and Calcutta and in the smaller cities and towns but the number
could easily exceed 2 million.
It is common to see individuals and families taking shelter where they can
under flyovers, in culverts or in large water pipes. Those that sleep on
the pavements are often reported to have been run-over by rashly driven
vehicles.
A joint-survey conducted by the union ministry of welfare and Unicef about
10 years ago estimated the population of street children alone in eight
cities to be about half a million. More recent studies in Delhi by
voluntary agencies estimate the number of the shelterless at more than
100,000 - nearly a third of them street-children.
A scheme for the welfare of street children was launched in 1993 to
provide community-based care of street children and this scheme is being
implemented through 81 voluntary organizations in 23 cities.
Additionally, the urban homeless are covered by a government scheme
providing night-shelters and sanitary facilities for pavement dwellers.
But the needs of no more than 10 percent of the 2 million urban homeless
are likely to have been covered.
If slum dwellers, many of whom fall under the category of the
''precariously housed'', because of sheer flimsiness or because they stand
to be bulldozed by authorities at short notice, the numbers of the urban
shelterless would run into tens of millions.
While homeless women are far less in number than are the men, the
difficulties they face in meeting sanitation and shelter needs are severe
because facilities simply do not exist for them.
No attempt has been made to secure for the homeless surplus lands which
could readily be used to construct shelters or housing schemes. Most of
the land is eyed by builders and land sharks. A Planning Commission
document admits the ''failure to curb or prevent concentration of urban
land holdings, profiteering and ensure equitable distribution of land''.
Records show barely 8 percent of 220,000 hectares of land declared surplus
as having been taken over by the government for housing development for
poorer sections of the people.
On top of it there are mistaken notions regarding the homeless such as
that they lack community ties and are likely to remain a floating
population incapable of forming close community ties. Take Kalimuddin's
case. Though shelterless he is part of a group of about 20 people from
Bihar who, like him, sell ice water for a living. ''We stick by each other
in times of trouble because we come from the same state and speak the same
language and have a common culture,'' says Kalimuddin.
Indeed it could be said that India's pavement dwellers have a better sense
of community spirit than well-to-do folk who live in posh colonies but
often do not even acknowledge each other's presence.
Many of the pavement dwellers are, like Kalimuddin or Jaswinder, economic
refugees who have had to leave their villages because of diminishing
returns from tilling the land, failure of crops or natural disasters.
Illiterate and uncomprehending of the ways of cities these villagers
settle down to existences which are worse than the ones they left behind.
Often the only comfort they get in times of trouble comes from each other.
It has been argued that this sense of community spirit could easily be
tapped to involve them in the planning and management of shelters or other
arrangements. According to voluntary agencies, when asked, footpath
dwellers readily agree to cooperate in the management of night-shelters if
only these could be built for them by the government.
But for that the government has to, first of all, officially acknowledge
the presence of pavement dwellers.